Traderswithedge.com Review

Based on looking at the website Traderswithedge.com, it appears to be a prop trading firm offering “funded accounts” to traders who successfully pass a series of challenges. The core idea is that traders pay a participation fee to prove their skills on a demo account, and if they meet certain profit targets without exceeding loss limits, they get to trade with the firm’s capital, sharing in the profits. However, the nature of prop trading, especially when involving upfront fees for challenges and a focus on speculative financial instruments, raises significant ethical concerns within Islamic finance principles. The fundamental issue lies in the presence of riba interest through leveraged trading and the element of gharar excessive uncertainty/speculation inherent in highly volatile markets, which can lead to disproportionate risk without tangible asset exchange.

Here’s an overall review summary:

• Service Offered: Prop trading firm providing capital to successful traders after they pass challenges.
• Key Features: Offers various account sizes from $5,000 to $1,000,000, profit splits up to 80% for the trader, scaling plans up to $3 million, and multiple challenge types 1-phase, 2-phase, instant.
• Pricing: Participation fees range from $55 to $15,000 with discounts offered, depending on the challenge type and capital size.
• Tradable Assets: FX Majors, Minors, Exotics, Global Market Indices, Metals, Commodities, Digital Assets, AU/US Stocks.
• Platforms: Match Trader, DX Trade, and two unnamed “Platform 4” and “Platform 5”.
• Ethical Standpoint Islamic Finance: Not Recommended. The core business model involves elements of riba interest through leverage and gharar excessive speculation in financial markets without real underlying asset transactions. Trading in FX, indices, commodities often futures or CFDs, and digital assets via leveraged accounts frequently involves contracts that do not meet Islamic finance criteria for permissibility.
• Transparency: The website provides detailed terms for challenges, including profit targets, max daily loss, and max overall loss, which is good for transparency within its operational model. However, the ethical implications for a Muslim user are not addressed.
• Customer Support & Community: Mentions Discord community, customer testimonials, and quick email replies, suggesting some focus on user support.

While the concept of sharing profits might seem appealing, the underlying mechanisms of leveraged trading and speculative contracts in the financial markets, as offered by Traderswithedge.com, generally fall outside the permissible boundaries of Islamic finance.

Transactions should ideally be based on real assets, involve clear ownership and transfer, and avoid interest-bearing debt or excessive uncertainty.

Therefore, for those seeking to align their financial activities with Islamic principles, this platform is not suitable.

0.0 0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews) Excellent0% Very good0% Average0% Poor0% Terrible0% There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. Your review Your overall rating Select a Rating5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star Title of your review Your review Your name Your email This review is based on my own experience and is my genuine opinion. ​ Submit Review

Amazon.com: Check Amazon for Traderswithedge.com Review Latest Discussions & Reviews:

Instead of engaging in speculative trading, consider ethical and permissible alternatives for wealth growth and financial engagement.

Focus on avenues that promote real economic activity, asset-backed investments, and clear, transparent transactions devoid of Riba and excessive Gharar.

Best Ethical Alternatives for Financial Growth:

1. Halal Investment Funds:

   

   • Key Features: Professionally managed funds investing in Sharia-compliant stocks, real estate, and other permissible assets. Avoids industries like alcohol, gambling, and interest-based finance.
   • Price: Management fees typically range from 0.5% to 2.0% annually of assets under management.
   • Pros: Diversified portfolio, expert management, aligns with Islamic principles, passive income potential.
   • Cons: Returns may be lower than highly speculative investments, less control over individual asset selection.

2. Ethical Real Estate Investment Trusts REITs:

   • Key Features: Invests in income-generating real estate properties, allowing individuals to earn rental income and capital appreciation without direct property management.
   • Price: Share price varies. transaction fees apply when buying/selling.
   • Pros: Tangible asset-backed investment, potential for steady income, aligns with Islamic principles as it involves ownership of real assets.
   • Cons: Market fluctuations can affect value, liquidity might be lower than stocks.

3. Equity Crowdfunding Platforms Sharia-Compliant:

   • Key Features: Invest directly in startups and growing businesses, becoming an equity owner rather than a lender. Focus on businesses with ethical operations.
   • Price: Varies based on investment amount. platform fees may apply.
   • Pros: Supports real businesses, potential for high returns, direct ownership, aligns with Islamic principles of partnership and risk-sharing.
   • Cons: High risk, illiquid investments, requires thorough due diligence.

4. Sukuk Islamic Bonds:

   • Key Features: Asset-backed securities structured to comply with Sharia law, providing investors with a share of profits generated by the underlying assets, rather than interest.
   • Price: Market-driven prices, varying based on issuance and demand.
   • Pros: Low risk compared to equity, income generation, Sharia-compliant, supports infrastructure and real projects.
   • Cons: Returns might be modest, limited availability for retail investors in some markets.

5. Halal Gold and Silver Investments:

   • Key Features: Investing in physical gold or silver, or Sharia-compliant gold/silver ETFs, as a store of value and hedge against inflation.
   • Price: Varies with market prices. storage fees for physical assets.
   • Pros: Tangible asset, historically stable, permissible as a store of wealth.
   • Cons: No income generation unless leased out, with specific conditions, storage and insurance costs for physical.

6. Ethical Microfinance Initiatives:

   • Key Features: Provides small loans or equity investments to entrepreneurs and small businesses in underserved communities, fostering economic development. Often structured without interest.
   • Price: Varies based on the specific initiative. may involve philanthropic or investment contributions.
   • Pros: Socially impactful, supports real economic activity, potential for shared returns if structured as investment, aligns with Islamic principles of social justice.
   • Cons: Can be higher risk depending on the project, lower direct financial returns if primarily philanthropic.

7. Permissible Business Ventures/Partnerships:

   • Key Features: Direct investment or partnership in a business that operates within Sharia principles, sharing in its profits and losses. This embodies the true spirit of Islamic commerce.
   • Price: Highly variable, depending on the business.
   • Pros: Direct involvement in real economic activity, aligns perfectly with Islamic finance principles of risk-sharing and ethical conduct, potential for significant returns.
   • Cons: Requires active participation or thorough due diligence, higher risk than diversified funds, less liquidity.

---

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

Traderswithedge.com Review: A Deeper Dive into the Prop Trading Landscape

Navigating the world of online financial opportunities can feel like trekking through a dense jungle.

Every other corner, there’s a new “paradigm shift” or a “guaranteed path to riches.” Traderswithedge.com positions itself as a prop trading firm, aiming to provide capital to skilled traders.

They dangle the carrot of up to $3 million in funding and an 80% profit split.

On the surface, that sounds like an enticing proposition for anyone looking to scale their trading without risking their own substantial capital.

But let’s be real, whenever large sums of money and high returns are involved, a healthy dose of skepticism is absolutely essential, especially when we consider the ethical guidelines that govern our financial dealings. Chuffed.org Review

The model these prop firms use, including Traderswithedge.com, typically involves a “challenge” phase. You pay a fee, get access to a demo account, and then you’ve got to hit specific profit targets while staying within strict drawdown limits. If you nail it, they supposedly give you a funded account. The entire structure, from the “challenge” fees to the leveraged trading on various assets, immediately raises questions about its permissibility from an Islamic finance perspective. As seasoned investors know, high leverage and speculative trading often walk hand-in-hand with Riba interest and Gharar excessive uncertainty, both of which are strictly forbidden. It’s not just about the potential for profit. it’s about the means by which that profit is generated. We’re talking about fundamental principles here, not just minor details.

Understanding the Traderswithedge.com Business Model

Traderswithedge.com operates on a proprietary trading firm model, commonly known as a “prop firm.” The core premise is to identify talented traders by putting them through a rigorous evaluation process.

This process typically involves trading a simulated demo account with specific rules and performance metrics.

If a trader successfully navigates these challenges, they are then offered a “funded account” where they can trade with the firm’s capital and share in the profits they generate.

• The Challenge Phase: This is where the initial assessment happens. Traders pay a non-refundable “participation fee” to access a demo account. The fee structure on Traderswithedge.com varies significantly based on the chosen account size and challenge type 1-phase, 2-phase, or Instant. For example, a $5,000 “1 Phase – Turtle” challenge costs $55, while a $1,000,000 “1 Phase – Turtle” challenge goes for $5,997. During this phase, traders must achieve a specific profit target e.g., 10% for standard challenges while adhering to strict daily and overall drawdown limits e.g., 3% daily loss, 6% maximum loss for standard challenges.
• The Funded Account: Upon successful completion of the challenge, traders are supposedly provided with a funded account. Traderswithedge.com states they offer up to $3 million in funding and allow traders to keep 80% of the profits. Payouts are advertised as fortnightly.
• Scaling Plan: The firm also mentions a scaling plan, allowing traders to increase their funded capital if they consistently meet performance objectives. This scaling can eventually lead to being presented to “larger institutions” for funding up to $30 million after a minimum of 2 years of consistent trading with Traderswithedge.com.

The business model, while common in the prop trading industry, fundamentally revolves around speculative trading in financial markets. The “participation fees” for the challenges, combined with the leverage offered 1:100, and the focus on instruments like FX forex, indices, and digital assets, raise significant ethical flags under Islamic finance principles. Islamic finance generally prohibits transactions that involve riba interest, gharar excessive uncertainty or speculation, and maysir gambling. The use of leverage in currency trading, where you control a large sum with a small amount of your own capital, often involves interest-based mechanisms. Furthermore, the inherent speculative nature of day trading in highly volatile markets, aiming for quick gains without clear underlying asset transactions, can be problematic. Skim-a-round.com Review

Ethical Considerations of Traderswithedge.com

When we talk about financial dealings, especially from an Islamic perspective, it’s not just about whether you make money or lose money. It’s about how that money is made. The principles of Islamic finance are built on fairness, transparency, real economic activity, and avoiding exploitation and excessive risk. Traderswithedge.com, like many prop trading firms, operates in a space that inherently clashes with several of these core tenets.

• Riba Interest: The presence of leverage 1:100, according to their site in trading foreign exchange FX and other instruments is a major red flag. In conventional finance, leverage often involves borrowing money from a broker to increase trading size. This borrowing typically incurs interest, either explicit or embedded within swap rates for holding positions overnight. Even if the firm itself isn’t charging direct interest on your challenge fee, the underlying mechanics of leveraged trading in conventional markets are intertwined with interest-based transactions. Islamic finance strictly prohibits Riba, regardless of whether it’s charged or paid.
• Gharar Excessive Uncertainty/Speculation: Trading in highly volatile markets like FX, commodities often futures or CFDs, and digital assets involves a high degree of uncertainty. The objective is often to profit from price fluctuations rather than from the ownership or exchange of real, tangible assets. While a certain degree of risk is permissible in business, excessive and undefined risk, particularly in financial speculation where the outcome is largely a gamble, falls under Gharar. The rapid buying and selling of contracts without physical delivery or clear benefit derived from the underlying asset is problematic.
• Maysir Gambling: The line between speculation and gambling can be thin. When the primary intent is to make a quick profit from price movements in a zero-sum game, with a high chance of losing the initial “participation fee” if challenge rules are violated, it leans towards Maysir. The structure, where a fee is paid for a chance at a large payout contingent on a highly uncertain outcome, bears resemblance to gambling.
• Lack of Real Economic Activity: Islamic finance encourages investment in real economic activity—businesses that produce goods, provide services, and create tangible value. Trading FX pairs or indices in a highly speculative manner, even with a funded account, doesn’t contribute directly to real economic growth. It’s often a transfer of wealth based on price predictions, rather than value creation.

Given these points, for someone looking to conduct their financial affairs in a permissible way, engaging with a platform like Traderswithedge.com is not recommended. The structure, despite its seemingly high-reward potential, relies on mechanisms and engages in activities that are fundamentally at odds with Islamic financial principles. There are far more ethical and sustainable ways to build wealth that contribute to real economic well-being, rather than engaging in high-risk speculation with embedded impermissible elements.

How Traderswithedge.com Works

Traderswithedge.com outlines a straightforward, albeit challenging, path for aspiring funded traders.

The process is divided into distinct stages, each with its own set of rules and objectives.

1. Select Your Account Type and Capital: Vadermountaincapital.com Review

   • 1 Phase – Turtle: This is a single-stage evaluation. You pay a fee, trade a demo account, and aim for a specific profit target e.g., 10% for standard within certain loss limits e.g., 3% max daily, 6% max overall. The minimum time is 10 days, but there’s no maximum time limit. They offer standard and aggressive versions, with aggressive having higher profit targets 20% but also larger allowed drawdowns 5% max daily, 10% max overall.
   • 2 Phase – Hare: This involves two evaluation stages. You pay a fee and complete Phase 1 e.g., 10% profit target, 5% max daily loss, 10% max overall loss and then Phase 2 e.g., 5% profit target, same loss limits. Each phase has a minimum time of 5 days, with unlimited maximum time. Once both phases are passed, you get a funded account. Aggressive versions are also available with higher targets and loss limits.
   • Instant: This option seems to offer immediate access to a funded account after paying a “one-time desk fee,” but with a “capped at target” profit share 50%*, suggesting you only get a 50% split until a certain profit is made, after which the split presumably changes or the account scales. This model also has specific scaling targets e.g., 10% per level and static max loss limits 5% or 10% for aggressive.

2. Trade a Demo Account: Regardless of the chosen path, the initial trading always takes place on a demo account. This is crucial. You are not trading with real money from the firm during the challenge. You are proving your ability to trade profitability and manage risk within their defined parameters.

   • Profit Target: The percentage of profit you need to achieve on the demo account to pass the phase.
   • Max Daily Loss: The maximum percentage or dollar amount your account balance can drop in a single trading day from the starting balance of that day. Exceeding this fails the challenge.
   • Max Loss: The maximum percentage or dollar amount your account balance can drop overall from the initial starting balance of the challenge. Exceeding this also fails the challenge.
   • Min Time Days: The minimum number of trading days required to complete a phase.
   • Max Time Days: For most challenges, this is “Unlimited,” offering flexibility.

3. Become Funded: Once you pass all phases of your chosen challenge, Traderswithedge.com states they will fund you with real capital. You then become a “Trader With Edge” and keep a significant portion of the profits 80% for 1-phase and 2-phase accounts.

4. Scale Your Capital: The firm provides scaling plans, meaning if you continue to meet performance objectives on your funded account, they will increase your trading capital, potentially up to $3 million. This incentivizes consistent, disciplined trading.

5. Platforms and Assets: Traderswithedge.com mentions using Match Trader and DX Trade, along with “Platform 4” and “Platform 5.” They offer a wide range of tradable assets, including FX Majors, Minors, Exotics, Global Market Indices, Metals, Commodities, Digital Assets, and AU/US Stocks.

This structured approach, while common in the prop firm industry, is essentially a filtered entry point into speculative financial trading. Flyfairly.com Review

The initial fee acts as a barrier and a revenue source for the firm, while the strict rules weed out inconsistent traders, leaving only those who can demonstrate a specific kind of performance.

For those concerned with ethical financial practices, the underlying nature of the trading itself remains the primary concern, irrespective of the “challenge” mechanism.

Traderswithedge.com vs. Other Funding Models

It’s critical to understand how this model stacks up against other funding avenues, especially when considering ethical implications.

• Traditional Brokerage Accounts:

  • Traderswithedge.com: You trade the firm’s capital after passing a challenge and paying a fee. You keep a percentage of profits e.g., 80%.
  • Traditional Brokerage: You trade your own capital. You keep 100% of your profits minus commissions/fees.
  • Ethical View: Traditional brokerage accounts, while allowing you to control your own capital, still facilitate trading in speculative instruments like FX and CFDs, which raise Gharar and Riba concerns if leverage is involved or the underlying assets are problematic. However, if used for direct, spot transactions of permissible assets without leverage, it could be less problematic. Traderswithedge.com adds an extra layer of ethical concern with the upfront fee and the “challenge” structure, which can be seen as a form of Maysir.

• Venture Capital / Angel Investing: 60yr.com Review

  • Traderswithedge.com: Funds a trader’s speculative activities.
  • Venture Capital/Angel Investing: Funds actual businesses, products, or services. Investors take an equity stake in a company, sharing in its real-world success or failure.
  • Ethical View: Venture capital and angel investing, when directed towards ethical businesses not involved in forbidden activities like alcohol, gambling, interest-based finance, etc., are highly encouraged in Islamic finance. They represent direct investment in real economic activity and risk-sharing, which aligns with Mudarabah or Musharakah principles. This is a fundamentally different and more permissible approach to deploying capital.

• Bootstrapping a Business:

  • Traderswithedge.com: Offers capital for trading and profit-sharing based on market speculation.
  • Bootstrapping: Using your own savings or revenue to build and grow a business, directly participating in value creation.
  • Ethical View: Starting and growing a permissible business is perhaps the most encouraged form of wealth generation in Islam. It involves hard work, innovation, providing a valuable service or product, and directly contributing to the community. This aligns perfectly with ethical wealth creation, focusing on tangible results rather than financial maneuvers.

• Sharia-Compliant Funds e.g., Halal Equity Funds, Sukuk Funds:

  • Traderswithedge.com: Active, short-term, speculative trading model.
  • Sharia-Compliant Funds: Passive investment in a diversified portfolio of Sharia-approved stocks companies that meet ethical criteria, Islamic bonds Sukuk, or real estate. Focuses on long-term growth and asset-backed investments.
  • Ethical View: These funds are specifically designed to comply with Islamic finance principles, avoiding Riba, Gharar, and Maysir, and investing only in permissible sectors. They are an excellent alternative for those seeking ethical financial growth without engaging in direct trading activities.

In essence, while Traderswithedge.com offers a path to access larger trading capital, its operational model and the inherent nature of the activities it facilitates leveraged, speculative trading of volatile instruments put it squarely in conflict with key Islamic financial principles.

Alternatives focusing on real economic activity, asset-backed investments, and profit-sharing partnerships without interest or excessive speculation are far more aligned with permissible wealth generation.

Traderswithedge.com Pricing and Participation Fees

Understanding the pricing structure of Traderswithedge.com is crucial, as it represents the initial investment required to even attempt to gain access to their “funded” accounts. These are referred to as “Participation Fees” or “One Time Desk Fee.” It’s important to note that these fees are generally non-refundable, which is a standard practice across most prop trading firms. This non-refundable nature is a significant point when considering the ethical implications, as it means the firm earns revenue regardless of whether a trader passes the challenge or ultimately profits. Theanex.com Review

Here’s a breakdown of the fee structure, which varies based on the chosen account type and desired trading capital:

1 Phase – Turtle Account Standard

This challenge typically requires a 10% profit target with a 3% max daily loss and 6% max overall loss.

• $5,000 Account: $55
• $10,000 Account: $100
• $25,000 Account: $250 often discounted to $199
• $50,000 Account: $450 often discounted to $349
• $100,000 Account: $750 often discounted to $549
• $200,000 Account: $1,500 often discounted to $997
• $500,000 Account: $3,500 often discounted to $2,997
• $1,000,000 Account: $7,500 often discounted to $5,997

1 Phase – Turtle Account Aggressive

This challenge has a 20% profit target with a 5% max daily loss and 10% max overall loss. Primewall.io Review

• $5,000 Account: $110 often discounted to $88
• $10,000 Account: $200 often discounted to $160
• $25,000 Account: $500 often discounted to $400
• $50,000 Account: $900 often discounted to $720
• $100,000 Account: $1,500 often discounted to $1,200
• $200,000 Account: $3,000 often discounted to $2,400
• $500,000 Account: $7,000 often discounted to $5,600
• $1,000,000 Account: $15,000 often discounted to $12,000

2 Phase – Hare Account Standard

This challenge requires a 10% profit target in Phase 1 and 5% in Phase 2, with 5% max daily loss and 10% max overall loss.

Fees include a potential refund upon successful completion.

• $5,000 Account: $69
• $10,000 Account: $110
• $25,000 Account: $220
• $50,000 Account: $330
• $100,000 Account: $550
• $200,000 Account: $997
• $400,000 Account: $1,994

2 Phase – Hare Account Aggressive

This challenge requires a 20% profit target in Phase 1 and 10% in Phase 2, with 10% max daily loss and 20% max overall loss. Dentalpinclinic.com Review

• $5,000 Account: $138 often discounted to $110
• $10,000 Account: $220 often discounted to $176
• $25,000 Account: $440 often discounted to $352
• $50,000 Account: $660 often discounted to $528
• $100,000 Account: $1,100 often discounted to $880
• $200,000 Account: $1,994 often discounted to $1,595
• $400,000 Account: $3,988 often discounted to $3,190

Instant Account Standard

This account appears to offer immediate funding with a 50% profit share capped at target and 5% static max loss. There is a “One Time Desk Fee.”

• $2,500 Account: $125
• $5,000 Account: $250
• $10,000 Account: $500
• $20,000 Account: $1,000
• $40,000 Account: $2,000

Instant Account Aggressive

This account also offers immediate funding with a 50% profit share capped at target and 10% static max loss.

• $2,500 Account: $250 often discounted to $200
• $5,000 Account: $500 often discounted to $400
• $10,000 Account: $1,000 often discounted to $800
• $20,000 Account: $2,000 often discounted to $1,600
• $40,000 Account: $4,000 often discounted to $3,200

Key Observations on Pricing: Keababies.com Review

• High Initial Cost: The fees are substantial, especially for larger accounts. For instance, attempting to get a $1 million account could cost thousands of dollars upfront, with no guarantee of success or even a refund if the challenge is failed except for the 2-Phase Hare challenges that explicitly mention a refund upon success.
• Revenue Model: These fees are a primary source of revenue for prop firms. They profit from the sheer volume of applicants, knowing that only a small percentage will actually pass the challenges and even fewer will maintain profitability consistently enough to receive significant payouts. This model is often compared to a “lottery” by critics, where the firm is essentially selling expensive “tickets” for a low-probability chance at a large payout.
• Discounts: Traderswithedge.com frequently offers discounts on their participation fees, as indicated by the crossed-out original prices. This is a common marketing tactic to incentivize sign-ups.

From an ethical finance perspective, the non-refundable nature of these significant participation fees for what is essentially a “test” of skill on a demo account, whose outcome is uncertain and relies on speculative market activities, contributes to the Maysir gambling aspect. It’s a payment for a chance at something, rather than a direct exchange for a tangible service or product. While the firm states these fees are for “operating costs,” the structure remains problematic.

How to Cancel a Traderswithedge.com Subscription or Challenge

Since Traderswithedge.com operates on a challenge-based model rather than a recurring subscription, the concept of “canceling a subscription” isn’t directly applicable in the traditional sense.

Instead, if you’ve purchased a challenge, you’ve essentially made a one-time payment for an attempt at gaining a funded account.

Here’s how one might “cancel” or cease engagement with Traderswithedge.com:

• Failing the Challenge: The most common way to “cancel” a challenge is by simply failing it. If you breach any of the maximum daily loss or maximum overall loss limits, your challenge account will be terminated automatically. At this point, the participation fee you paid is generally non-refundable except for the 2-Phase Hare challenges where a refund is explicitly mentioned upon successful completion. You would then need to purchase a new challenge if you wish to try again.
• Voluntary Discontinuation: You can simply stop trading on the demo account provided for the challenge. There’s no ongoing obligation if you choose not to continue. The fee paid for that specific challenge attempt would still not be refunded.
• Not Activating the Account: If you purchase a challenge but never log in or start trading on the provided demo account, the challenge would likely expire after a certain period though the website mentions “Unlimited Max Time Days” for most challenges, it’s always best to check their detailed terms. Again, the fee would remain non-refundable.
• Cancellation of Funded Account: If you successfully pass a challenge and receive a funded account, and you wish to stop trading for the firm, you would likely need to formally notify them. The terms and conditions for terminating a funded account and receiving any due profit splits would be outlined in your agreement with them. Typically, a funded account can be paused or terminated by mutual agreement, or if performance rules are consistently violated.

Key Point: The “participation fees” are almost always upfront and non-refundable for the challenge itself. There isn’t a monthly subscription to cancel in the way you might cancel a Netflix account. If you’ve paid for a challenge and decide it’s not for you, the most direct “cancellation” is simply to stop participating, understanding that your initial fee will not be returned. Travelmoneyoz.com Review

For exact procedures regarding any potential refunds if applicable for specific challenge types or termination of funded accounts, it is imperative to consult Traderswithedge.com’s official “Terms & Conditions” and “Contact Us” pages. These documents legally bind both parties and will contain the precise details regarding account management and termination policies. Given the ethical concerns around the nature of the trading itself, the best approach for a conscientious individual might be to avoid engaging with such platforms in the first place, or if already engaged, to cease participation and seek out permissible alternatives.

Avoiding Financial Schemes and Promoting Ethical Wealth Growth

In a world brimming with promises of quick riches, discerning legitimate and ethical financial opportunities from those that are problematic or even outright scams is paramount.

Platforms like Traderswithedge.com, while not explicitly labeled as scams, operate in a high-risk, speculative domain that often has inherent ethical conflicts from an Islamic finance perspective.

The allure of “funded accounts” and high-profit splits can be incredibly tempting, but it’s crucial to understand the underlying mechanisms and potential pitfalls.

Why Caution is Key: Tesseract.academy Review

• High Failure Rates: Statistics from the conventional trading world consistently show that a vast majority of retail traders lose money. Prop firms, with their strict drawdown rules and demanding profit targets, essentially filter for the very small percentage of traders who can consistently perform. This means a significant portion of the “participation fees” paid by aspiring traders never translate into a funded account or profits.
• The House Always Wins: In models where upfront, non-refundable fees are charged for a chance at a speculative endeavor, the firm benefits regardless of the individual trader’s success. This creates an asymmetric risk profile where the firm’s revenue is relatively stable, while the individual trader bears significant financial and time risk.
• Ethical Compromise: As discussed, the core activities—leveraged trading, speculation in volatile markets FX, digital assets, derivatives—often involve elements of Riba interest and Gharar excessive uncertainty, making them impermissible. Engaging in such activities, even if profitable, compromises one’s ethical principles.
• Psychological Toll: The pressure to meet aggressive profit targets and avoid stringent loss limits can lead to immense stress, impulsive decisions, and poor judgment, further increasing the likelihood of financial losses and psychological distress.

Promoting Ethical Wealth Growth:

Instead of chasing speculative dreams that may compromise one’s principles, focus on building wealth through avenues that are demonstrably ethical, sustainable, and aligned with real economic value.

1. Direct Investment in Permissible Businesses:

   • Focus: Invest in or start businesses that produce tangible goods, offer essential services, or contribute positively to society e.g., sustainable agriculture, ethical technology, healthcare, education.
   • Model: This aligns with principles of Mudarabah profit-sharing partnership or Musharakah joint venture, where both profit and loss are shared based on mutual effort and capital contribution.
   • Example: Investing in a local, ethically-run bakery, a tech startup developing beneficial software, or a renewable energy project.

2. Asset-Backed Investments:

   • Focus: Acquire tangible assets that generate income or appreciate in value based on real economic factors.
   • Examples:
     • Real Estate: Purchasing property for rental income or long-term appreciation.
     • Commodities: Investing in physical gold, silver, or other permissible commodities with direct ownership, avoiding leveraged futures contracts.
     • Agricultural Land: Investing in productive land that yields crops.
   • Benefit: These investments are tied to real-world assets, reducing excessive speculation and often providing stable, predictable returns.

3. Sharia-Compliant Financial Products: Soulsanskar.com Review

   • Focus: Utilize financial products specifically designed to adhere to Islamic principles.
     • Halal Equity Funds: Mutual funds or ETFs that invest only in Sharia-compliant companies screened for industries like alcohol, gambling, interest-based finance, and excessive debt.
     • Sukuk Islamic Bonds: Asset-backed certificates that represent ownership in a real asset, providing a share of profits generated by that asset.
     • Takaful Islamic Insurance: Cooperative insurance schemes based on mutual assistance, avoiding Riba and Gharar found in conventional insurance.
   • Benefit: These options allow for diversified, professional management of investments while strictly adhering to ethical guidelines.

4. Skills Development and Value Creation:

   • Focus: Invest in yourself by acquiring valuable skills that can be leveraged to create income through legitimate employment, entrepreneurship, or consulting.
   • Example: Learning coding, digital marketing, skilled trades, or specialized consulting.
   • Benefit: This emphasizes earning through legitimate effort and expertise, a fundamental principle of permissible earning.

Building true wealth is a marathon, not a sprint.

It’s about consistent effort, smart decision-making, and aligning one’s actions with deeply held values.

While the quick gains promised by speculative trading might seem appealing, the risks—both financial and ethical—often outweigh the potential rewards.

Focus on durable, ethical paths that contribute to sustainable growth and peace of mind. Elegantspins.com Review

What Happens If You Violate Traderswithedge.com Rules?

When engaging with a prop trading firm like Traderswithedge.com, strict adherence to their rules is paramount.

These rules are designed to protect the firm’s capital and identify traders who can manage risk effectively.

Violating these rules results in the immediate termination of your challenge or funded account. There are typically two primary violations:

1. Maximum Daily Loss MDL Violation:

   • Definition: This rule specifies the maximum amount or percentage your account balance can drop within a single trading day from the starting equity of that day. For instance, if you have a $10,000 account with a 3% daily loss limit, your account cannot drop more than $300 from its starting balance on any given day.
   • Consequence: If your floating losses including open trades or closed losses exceed this limit at any point during the day, your challenge or funded account is immediately terminated.
   • Impact: Your current challenge attempt is over, and you forfeit the participation fee paid for that challenge. If it’s a funded account, you lose the ability to trade with their capital and any accrued but unpaid profits.

2. Maximum Loss Overall/Static Violation: Anthbot.com Review

   • Definition: This rule specifies the absolute maximum amount or percentage your account balance can drop from the initial starting balance of the challenge or funded account. For a $10,000 account with a 6% max loss, your account equity cannot drop below $9,400 at any point during the challenge. For “Instant” accounts, this is often a “Static Max Loss” from the initial balance.
   • Consequence: Similar to the daily loss, exceeding this limit results in immediate termination of the account.
   • Impact: As with the MDL violation, your challenge attempt is forfeited, and the participation fee is lost. For funded accounts, it means account termination and loss of trading privileges.

Key Implications of Violations:

• Immediate Termination: Unlike traditional personal trading accounts where you might get a margin call, prop firms often have an automated system that shuts down your account as soon as a rule is breached. This is non-negotiable.
• Loss of Participation Fee: For challenge accounts, the upfront fee you paid is typically non-refundable once a violation occurs unless specified otherwise, like in some 2-phase challenges with a success-based refund. This is a critical point that highlights the firm’s revenue model: they make money from the volume of challenge attempts, many of which fail due to these strict rules.
• No Second Chances for that attempt: Once an account is violated, that specific challenge attempt is over. If you wish to try again, you must purchase a new challenge.
• Psychological Pressure: The constant pressure of these strict loss limits can be psychologically demanding for traders. It can lead to overthinking, hesitation, or desperate “revenge trading” after small losses, which often spirals into larger violations.

From an ethical perspective, the strict, unforgiving nature of these rules, combined with the non-refundable fees, places a significant burden of risk on the individual trader who is paying to attempt to prove their skills. While risk management is crucial in any financial endeavor, the structure here creates a scenario where the “house” the prop firm has a very clear advantage, profiting from the statistical likelihood of traders hitting these loss limits. This reinforces the problematic aspects of Maysir gambling-like activity and Gharar excessive uncertainty for the participant inherent in such models.

Traderswithedge.com Tradable Assets

Traderswithedge.com advertises a wide range of tradable assets, aiming to provide flexibility for traders with different preferences and strategies.

This variety is often a selling point for prop firms, as it allows traders to apply their skills across multiple markets.

However, it’s important to understand the nature of these assets, especially from an Islamic finance perspective. Getquietlab.com Review

Here’s a breakdown of the asset classes mentioned on their homepage:

• FX Majors, Minors, Exotics Forex:

  • Description: This refers to foreign exchange currency pairs. “Majors” are the most heavily traded e.g., EUR/USD, GBP/USD, “Minors” involve major currencies against each other e.g., EUR/GBP, and “Exotics” involve a major currency against a less common currency e.g., USD/TRY.
  • Islamic View: Forex trading is highly debated. While spot currency exchange where currencies are exchanged immediately, hand-to-hand is permissible, the vast majority of online FX trading, especially with leverage, does not involve immediate physical exchange. Instead, it’s contract-based, often with rollover interest swap fees charged or paid for positions held overnight. This introduces Riba interest and Gharar excessive uncertainty/speculation, rendering most leveraged retail forex trading impermissible.

• Global Market Indices:

  • Description: These are instruments that track the performance of a basket of stocks from a particular market or sector e.g., S&P 500, NASDAQ 100, DAX. Trading indices typically involves Contract for Differences CFDs or futures, not direct ownership of the underlying stocks.
  • Islamic View: Trading CFDs on indices is generally considered impermissible due to the high level of Gharar speculation without tangible asset exchange and potential Maysir gambling elements. There’s no real transfer of ownership of the underlying stocks, and the primary aim is often short-term price speculation.

• Metals:

  • Description: This usually refers to precious metals like gold XAU/USD and silver XAG/USD. Similar to FX and indices, trading these often involves CFDs or futures, not physical delivery.
  • Islamic View: While physical gold and silver are permissible assets and historical forms of currency, trading them through leveraged CFDs or futures contracts often introduces Riba if interest is involved in financing the leverage and Gharar if the contract is not for immediate physical delivery and involves excessive speculation, making it problematic.

• Commodities:

  • Description: This category includes energy e.g., crude oil, natural gas, agricultural products e.g., corn, wheat, and other raw materials. Again, trading is typically via CFDs or futures.
  • Islamic View: Similar to metals, while the physical commodities themselves are permissible, trading them speculatively through leveraged derivatives CFDs, futures without actual ownership, delivery, or clear benefit from the underlying asset, often involves Gharar and Maysir, making it impermissible.

• Digital Assets:

  • Description: This refers to cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc. Trading can involve spot purchases, but often leveraged derivatives are offered.
  • Islamic View: The permissibility of cryptocurrencies themselves is a complex and ongoing debate among scholars. However, trading them with high leverage and for purely speculative purposes, without any real economic activity or tangible use case beyond price appreciation, would likely fall under the concerns of Gharar and Maysir, similar to other speculative instruments.

• AU, US Stocks:

  • Description: This refers to stocks listed on Australian and US stock exchanges.
  • Islamic View: Investing in stocks can be permissible if the underlying company’s business activities are Sharia-compliant e.g., not involved in alcohol, gambling, interest-based finance, pork, immoral entertainment. However, trading stocks through leveraged CFDs Contract for Differences or engaging in frequent day trading solely for price speculation can introduce Gharar and Maysir. Direct ownership of Sharia-compliant stocks, held for long-term growth and dividend income, is generally permissible.

In summary, while Traderswithedge.com offers a broad spectrum of assets, the method of trading them leveraged and speculative through contracts is the primary concern for ethical finance. The business model encourages a type of engagement with these markets that is often impermissible, even if the underlying assets, in certain forms, could be permissible. For a Muslim, focusing on real asset ownership and avoiding highly speculative and interest-laden financial instruments is key.

FAQ

How does Traderswithedge.com identify skilled traders?

Traderswithedge.com identifies skilled traders through a rigorous evaluation process involving various “challenge” accounts 1-Phase Turtle, 2-Phase Hare, Instant where aspiring traders must meet specific profit targets while adhering to strict daily and overall loss limits on a demo account.

What is the profit split offered by Traderswithedge.com?

Traderswithedge.com advertises that successful traders on their funded accounts can keep up to 80% of the profits they generate, with payouts typically occurring fortnightly.

Are there any upfront fees to join Traderswithedge.com?

Yes, Traderswithedge.com charges non-refundable “participation fees” or “one-time desk fees” to access their challenge accounts.

These fees vary significantly based on the chosen challenge type and the desired virtual capital size.

What are the maximum daily loss and overall loss limits at Traderswithedge.com?

For standard challenges, the maximum daily loss is typically 3% of the initial account balance, and the maximum overall loss is 6%. Aggressive challenges have higher limits, usually 5% daily and 10% overall.

Instant accounts have static max loss limits e.g., 5% or 10%.

Can I trade all asset classes offered by Traderswithedge.com?

Traderswithedge.com offers trading in FX Majors, Minors, Exotics, Global Market Indices, Metals, Commodities, Digital Assets, and AU/US Stocks, allowing traders to choose from a wide range of instruments once they are part of the program.

Is leveraged trading permissible on Traderswithedge.com?

Yes, Traderswithedge.com explicitly states they offer account leverage up to 1:100. However, the use of leverage in financial trading, particularly in FX and derivatives, often involves interest-based mechanisms Riba and excessive speculation Gharar, which are generally not permissible.

Does Traderswithedge.com offer a free trial?

Based on the provided homepage text, Traderswithedge.com does not explicitly offer a free trial.

All challenge types require an upfront “participation fee” to begin.

How often are payouts made by Traderswithedge.com?

Traderswithedge.com states that payouts for funded traders are made fortnightly, which means every two weeks.

What trading platforms does Traderswithedge.com support?

Traderswithedge.com supports Match Trader and DX Trade, along with two unnamed platforms referred to as “Platform 4” and “Platform 5.”

Can Expert Advisors EAs or automated trading be used on Traderswithedge.com?

Yes, Traderswithedge.com explicitly states that Expert Advisors EAs are allowed for use in their trading challenges and funded accounts.

Are there any restrictions on news trading with Traderswithedge.com?

No, Traderswithedge.com permits news trading, indicating that traders can open or close positions around major economic news releases.

Can I hold trades over the weekend with Traderswithedge.com?

Yes, Traderswithedge.com allows weekend holding, meaning traders can keep their positions open over the weekend.

What is the scaling plan at Traderswithedge.com?

Traderswithedge.com offers account scaling plans, where consistent profitability on a funded account can lead to an increase in trading capital, potentially up to $3 million.

What happens if I fail a challenge at Traderswithedge.com?

If you fail a challenge by exceeding the daily or overall loss limits, your challenge account is immediately terminated, and the participation fee paid for that attempt is typically forfeited and non-refundable.

Does Traderswithedge.com provide educational resources or mentoring?

Yes, the website mentions that joining their community allows for discussions, access to courses, and mentoring to help funded traders unlock their full potential.

Is Traderswithedge.com a broker?

No, Traderswithedge.com explicitly states in its disclaimer that it is “not a broker, does not accept deposits for brokers and does not provide any investment services.” It operates by offering virtual accounts for challenges and then funds traders with its own capital.

How long does it take to pass a Traderswithedge.com challenge?

The minimum time to pass a challenge varies: 10 days for 1-Phase challenges and 5 days per phase for 2-Phase challenges.

There is typically no maximum time limit, providing flexibility.

What is the difference between a “Standard” and “Aggressive” challenge at Traderswithedge.com?

Standard challenges have lower profit targets and tighter drawdown limits e.g., 10% target, 3% daily loss, 6% overall loss, while Aggressive challenges have higher profit targets and looser drawdown limits e.g., 20% target, 5% daily loss, 10% overall loss.

How does Traderswithedge.com ensure payouts?

Traderswithedge.com claims to ensure payouts by partnering with “Symbiosis Capital and other investment firms,” stating that eligible traders who should be paid, are paid.

Where is Traderswithedge.com operated from?

Traderswithedge.com Hong Kong Limited operates from Unit 1603, 16th Floor, The L.

Plaza, 367 – 375 Queen’s Road Central, Sheung Wan, Hong Kong, and RM 2103 Futura Plaza 111, How Ming St Kwun Tong, Hong Kong.

However, it does not accept residents from Hong Kong, Australia, Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Sudan, or Syria.