
Based on checking the website, Fellows.co.uk is an established UK auction house that handles a wide variety of items. While they offer a broad range of services including valuations and diverse auction departments, certain aspects of their offerings, such as Jewellery, Pawnbroking, Watches, and Wine & Spirits, along with the general nature of auctions themselves, require careful consideration from an ethical perspective. Auctions, by their nature, can involve elements of gharar (excessive uncertainty) and speculation, which are generally discouraged. The inclusion of departments like ‘Jewellery’ (which often involves precious metals and potentially interest-bearing transactions in the broader market, though not explicitly stated on their site), ‘Pawnbroking’ (inherently linked to interest-based lending), and ‘Wine & Spirits’ (explicitly forbidden) raises significant concerns regarding their alignment with ethical principles.
Overall Review Summary:
- Website Transparency: Good, with clear sections for departments, history, FAQs, and contact.
- User Experience: Appears well-organised with easy navigation to auction listings and services.
- Ethical Compliance (Key Concern): Highly problematic due to the inclusion of ‘Pawnbroking’ and ‘Wine & Spirits’ departments, both of which deal in explicitly forbidden transactions and products. The general nature of auctions also carries a risk of gharar and speculation.
- Security Features: Standard account creation process with password requirements; Trustpilot link indicates external review presence.
- Customer Support: Clearly listed contact numbers and a ‘Contact Us’ section.
- Product/Service Diversity: Broad, but this diversity includes ethically questionable categories.
- Overall Recommendation: Not recommended due to direct involvement in forbidden categories and the inherent nature of certain auction practices that could conflict with ethical principles.
While Fellows.co.uk presents itself as a reputable and established auction house, its services directly involve areas that are explicitly not recommended. The presence of ‘Pawnbroking’ and ‘Wine & Spirits’ departments is a major red flag, as these categories deal in transactions and products that are considered forbidden. Pawnbroking typically involves interest (riba), which is strictly forbidden, and the trade of wine and spirits is clearly impermissible. Furthermore, the general mechanism of auctions, particularly those involving items like jewellery (which can often be tied to speculative value or even potentially interest-bearing transactions in a wider financial context), can introduce elements of excessive uncertainty (gharar) and speculation, which are discouraged. For those seeking ethically sound transactions, engaging with a platform that facilitates such activities is best avoided.
Here are some alternatives for acquiring items ethically:
- Handmade Ceramics:
- Key Features: Unique artistry, practical use, decorative elements.
- Average Price: £20-£150 per piece, depending on size and artist.
- Pros: Supports artisans, offers tangible and useful items, often made from natural materials.
- Cons: Can be fragile, limited mass production, pricing varies widely.
- Ethical Home Textiles:
- Key Features: Sustainably sourced materials (e.g., organic cotton, linen), fair trade production, diverse designs.
- Average Price: £30-£200 for throws, cushions, or small rugs.
- Pros: Promotes responsible consumption, comfortable and aesthetically pleasing, supports ethical labour.
- Cons: Can be more expensive than mass-produced alternatives, limited design options in some ethical brands.
- Vintage Books & Manuscripts:
- Key Features: Historical value, unique insights, potential for collecting, non-perishable.
- Average Price: £10-£500+, depending on rarity and condition.
- Pros: Educational, culturally enriching, a tangible connection to the past, no ethical concerns related to production.
- Cons: Condition can vary, requires careful storage, finding specific rare items can be challenging.
- Antique Furniture:
- Key Features: Durable craftsmanship, unique designs, historical character.
- Average Price: £100-£1000+, highly variable.
- Pros: Sustainable (reusing existing items), often higher quality than modern equivalents, adds character to a space.
- Cons: Can be heavy and difficult to transport, may require restoration, limited availability of specific styles.
- Hand-blown Glassware:
- Key Features: Artistic designs, vibrant colours, functional or decorative.
- Average Price: £25-£200 per item.
- Pros: Unique pieces, supports skilled artisans, adds elegance to a home.
- Cons: Fragile, can be pricey, may not be practical for everyday use.
- Art Prints & Illustrations:
- Key Features: Wide range of styles and subjects, accessible pricing, can transform a space.
- Average Price: £15-£150, depending on size and artist.
- Pros: Supports artists, allows for personal expression, easily interchangeable.
- Cons: Can lack the texture of original art, quality varies, framing may be an additional cost.
- High-Quality Stationery Sets:
- Key Features: Premium paper, elegant designs, useful for writing or gifting.
- Average Price: £20-£80.
- Pros: Practical, encourages traditional writing, can be used for personal correspondence or professional notes.
- Cons: Can be seen as a luxury item, some sets may have limited components.
Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. |
Amazon.com:
Check Amazon for Fellows.co.uk Review Latest Discussions & Reviews: |
IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.
[ratemypost]
Fellows.co.uk Review & Ethical Concerns
Fellows.co.uk presents itself as a long-standing and trusted auction house in the UK, with a history dating back to 1876. While its longevity and established presence might suggest reliability, a closer look at its offerings reveals significant ethical considerations, particularly concerning the services and products it deals in. The presence of specific departments, as detailed on their homepage, raises red flags for individuals seeking to adhere to principles of responsible consumption and finance.
Overview of Fellows.co.uk Operations
Fellows.co.uk operates as an auctioneer, facilitating the buying and selling of a wide array of items through its online platform and physical auction rooms. They highlight their status as a family-run, independent firm with specialist auctions. Their website provides a comprehensive list of departments, indicating the breadth of their inventory.
- Established History: Founded in 1876, Fellows.co.uk emphasizes its deep roots in the UK auction scene. This long history can be a positive indicator of experience and market knowledge.
- Global Reach: They claim their in-house shipping services and bidding technology have expanded their reach globally, allowing them to cater to an international as well as local clientele. This indicates a modern approach to the auction business.
- Diverse Departments: The list of departments is extensive, covering everything from ‘Advertising & Ephemera’ to ‘Watches’ and ‘Wine & Spirits’. This wide range is a key aspect of their business model.
Key Ethical Red Flags on Fellows.co.uk
The primary concern with Fellows.co.uk from an ethical standpoint stems directly from several of their advertised departments and services. These areas conflict directly with principles of responsible finance and permissible trade.
- Pawnbroking: This department is explicitly listed. Pawnbroking inherently involves interest-based lending (riba), where items are used as collateral for loans, and a fee (interest) is charged for the service. Riba is strictly forbidden, making any direct or indirect involvement in such transactions impermissible.
- Wine & Spirits: This department, clearly stated on their homepage, deals in the auction of alcoholic beverages. The production, sale, purchase, or consumption of alcohol is explicitly forbidden, thus any platform facilitating its trade is problematic.
- Jewellery & Watches: While not inherently problematic, the sale and purchase of gold and silver jewellery and watches through auctions can involve elements of gharar (excessive uncertainty) and speculation. In the context of auctions, the final price is unknown until the hammer falls, which adds a layer of uncertainty to the transaction that can be discouraged in certain financial dealings, especially with precious metals. Furthermore, the broader industry for these items can sometimes be intertwined with financial practices that are not permissible, though Fellows.co.uk does not explicitly mention these on their site.
- General Auction Mechanism: Auctions, by their very nature, involve bidding and often lead to prices that fluctuate based on competitive demand. This can sometimes stray into speculative territory, where the true value of an item is less important than the desire to outbid others. While not all auctions are inherently problematic, those dealing in commodities or financial instruments where the value is highly volatile can be a concern.
How Fellows.co.uk Operates: The Auction Process
Understanding how Fellows.co.uk conducts its auctions is crucial to assessing its services. The general process involves valuation, consignment, public display, and then the actual bidding process.
Valuation and Consignment
Before an item can be sold through Fellows.co.uk, it undergoes a valuation process. The website offers “Free Valuations,” indicating the initial step for those looking to sell their items. Completestoves.co.uk Review
- Free Valuations: Sellers can submit items for a professional appraisal to determine their potential auction value. This service is a standard practice for auction houses.
- Consignment Agreement: Once a valuation is agreed upon, sellers consign their items to Fellows.co.uk, granting them the right to sell the items on their behalf. This agreement typically outlines the terms, including commission rates and any other fees.
Auction Previews and Bidding
Fellows.co.uk facilitates both physical and online viewing of items, followed by a structured bidding process that caters to various participant preferences.
- Catalogue and Viewing: For each auction, a detailed catalogue is made available, often with high-resolution images and descriptions. Physical viewing times are also scheduled, allowing potential buyers to inspect items firsthand. This transparency in presenting items is a positive aspect.
- Bidding Mechanisms: Fellows.co.uk supports various bidding methods:
- Live Online Bidding: Through their “Fellows LIVE NOW” platform, bidders can participate in real-time auctions from anywhere in the world.
- Commission Bids: Bidders can leave a maximum bid with the auction house, which will then bid on their behalf up to that limit.
- Telephone Bidding: For higher-value lots, bidders can arrange to bid over the phone with a representative.
- Auction Results and Payment: After an auction, results are published, and successful bidders are required to make payment, including buyer’s premium and any applicable taxes. The website includes a “MAKE A PAYMENT” link, indicating a streamlined payment process.
Customer Support and Website Features
Fellows.co.uk offers various channels for customer support and incorporates features designed to enhance the user experience, particularly for bidders and sellers.
Contact and Assistance Channels
They provide clear contact information and a comprehensive ‘About Us’ section.
- Direct Contact Information: Two UK phone numbers are prominently displayed for their Birmingham and London offices: +44 121 212 2131 and +44 20 7127 4198. This direct access is beneficial for queries.
- Online Contact Form: A ‘Contact Us’ page is available for email inquiries.
- FAQs and Glossary: The website features an extensive FAQ section addressing common questions about buying, selling, and general auction processes. A glossary of terms is also provided, which can be particularly helpful for new participants in auctions.
- ‘Meet the Team’ Section: This adds a personal touch, allowing users to see the individuals behind the operation.
Website Functionality and User Accounts
The platform includes features aimed at improving engagement and personalising the user experience.
- My Fellows Account: Users can create an account to manage their bids, create wishlists, view auction archives, manage invoices, and set email alert preferences. This centralises user activity.
- Personalised Lot Alerts: A notable feature is the ability to set up “personalised keyword alerts” for specific items or categories. This allows users to be notified when new catalogues go live with items matching their interests, which can be useful for collectors.
- Blog and News Section: Fellows.co.uk maintains a blog with articles on various topics related to their departments, such as ‘The History of the Les Paul Guitar’ or profiles of artists. This content marketing helps engage visitors and provides industry insights.
- Calendar View: A full calendar of upcoming auctions is available, allowing users to plan their participation in advance.
Pros & Cons of Fellows.co.uk
Given the comprehensive review, it’s essential to summarise the advantages and disadvantages of using Fellows.co.uk, especially when considering ethical principles. Clelandpharmacy.co.uk Review
Cons of Fellows.co.uk
The main drawbacks are heavily concentrated on ethical non-compliance.
- Direct Involvement in Forbidden Transactions: As highlighted, the explicit inclusion of ‘Pawnbroking’ and ‘Wine & Spirits’ departments is a major ethical barrier. These services and products are strictly impermissible, making the platform unsuitable for those seeking to avoid such dealings.
- Risk of Gharar and Speculation: The nature of auctions, particularly for certain valuable items like watches and jewellery, can introduce excessive uncertainty regarding the final price and foster a speculative environment, which is discouraged.
- No Explicit Ethical Compliance Measures: There is no visible information on their website indicating any adherence to ethical guidelines for financial transactions or permissible goods, which is a significant omission for a platform dealing with such sensitive categories.
- Focus on Luxury Items: A significant portion of their offerings revolves around luxury items, which can encourage excessive consumerism and a focus on material wealth, potentially distracting from more meaningful pursuits.
Why Fellows.co.uk Is Not Recommended
For individuals adhering to ethical principles, Fellows.co.uk is not recommended primarily due to its direct involvement in forbidden transactions and products. The presence of ‘Pawnbroking’ means dealing with interest (riba), and the ‘Wine & Spirits’ department involves the trade of alcohol. Both are clear violations. While they offer a wide range of goods, the inclusion of these specific categories makes the platform unsuitable.
Alternatives to Fellows.co.uk
Given the ethical concerns with Fellows.co.uk, exploring alternative platforms that align with principles of ethical trade and consumption is essential. Instead of engaging in auctions that may involve speculation or forbidden items, focus on direct sales, clear value, and permissible goods.
Ethical Platforms for Collectables and Antiques
When seeking unique or historical items, consider platforms that focus on transparent sales and avoid problematic categories.
- Etsy (UK for Handmade & Vintage):
- Focus: Handmade crafts, vintage items (over 20 years old), art, and unique gifts. Sellers often disclose materials and processes.
- Ethical Aspect: Supports independent artisans and small businesses. Vintage items promote reuse. Buyers can vet individual shops for ethical practices.
- Dedicated Antique Dealers Online:
- Focus: Online marketplaces or individual websites of antique dealers specializing in specific categories like furniture, ceramics, or historical documents.
- Ethical Aspect: Direct purchase model, clearer pricing, and ability to verify the authenticity and provenance with the dealer.
- AbeBooks (for Rare & Collectable Books):
- Focus: Vast marketplace for new, used, rare, and out-of-print books from independent booksellers worldwide.
- Ethical Aspect: Promotes literacy and the preservation of knowledge. Direct sale, no speculative bidding.
Ethical Sourcing for Home Goods and Decor
For items to furnish or decorate a home, prioritise sustainability, fair trade, and non-problematic materials. Llechweddmeats.co.uk Review
- The Ethical Superstore (UK):
- Focus: Wide range of ethical products, including home and garden items, fair trade goods, and eco-friendly alternatives.
- Ethical Aspect: Strict vetting process for suppliers to ensure fair trade, organic, and sustainable practices.
- Traidcraft (UK):
- Focus: Pioneer of fair trade, offering homeware, crafts, food, and gifts.
- Ethical Aspect: Guarantees fair wages, safe working conditions, and sustainable practices for producers in developing countries.
General Ethical Shopping Principles
Beyond specific platforms, adopting general principles can guide all purchasing decisions.
- Direct Purchase over Auction: Opt for direct purchases where the price is clearly stated, reducing elements of gharar (uncertainty) and speculation inherent in bidding wars.
- Avoid Loan/Interest-Based Schemes: Steer clear of any platform that directly or indirectly promotes or facilitates interest-based transactions, such as pawnbroking or loans with interest.
- Verify Product Permissibility: Always ensure the product itself is permissible. This includes avoiding alcohol, gambling paraphernalia, or items that promote forbidden activities.
- Support Ethical Production: Prioritise items that are produced under fair labour conditions, are environmentally sustainable, and do not involve exploitation.
Fellows.co.uk Pricing and Fees
Understanding the cost structure for both buyers and sellers on Fellows.co.uk is essential, though it’s important to reiterate that these fees apply to transactions that include ethically problematic categories.
For Sellers: Commission and Charges
When selling items through Fellows.co.uk, various fees and charges are typically applied to the seller. While specific rates are usually detailed in a consignment agreement, common auction house fees include:
- Seller’s Commission: A percentage of the hammer price (the winning bid) that the auction house retains. This rate can vary based on the item’s value and category.
- Lotting Fees: Some auction houses charge a per-lot fee to cover administrative costs associated with cataloguing and preparing the item for auction.
- Insurance: Charges for insuring the item while it is in the auction house’s possession.
- Marketing/Photography Fees: Costs associated with professional photography and advertising of the item in catalogues and online.
- Withdrawal Fees: If a seller decides to withdraw an item after it has been consigned and catalogued, a fee may be charged.
- VAT: Value Added Tax applicable to fees and commissions.
For Buyers: Buyer’s Premium and Taxes
Buyers also incur additional costs beyond the hammer price.
- Buyer’s Premium: This is a percentage of the hammer price that the buyer must pay to the auction house. It is a standard charge in the auction industry and can range significantly (often 20-30% plus VAT).
- VAT on Buyer’s Premium: VAT is typically applied to the buyer’s premium.
- VAT on the Hammer Price: For certain items, especially those that are new or sold by VAT-registered businesses, VAT may also be applied to the hammer price.
- Artist’s Resale Right (ARR): For works of art, an additional royalty may be due to the artist or their estate, which is typically passed on to the buyer.
- Shipping and Handling: Costs for packing and shipping the purchased items, especially for international buyers.
Comparison: Fellows.co.uk vs. Other Auction Houses
While a direct comparison with other auction houses highlights their business models, it’s crucial to remember the ethical concerns that apply broadly to the auction industry. Many traditional auction houses share similar practices to Fellows.co.uk, including dealing in problematic categories. Hujjatbookshop.co.uk Review
Similarities Across Traditional Auction Houses
Most established auction houses operate with similar core principles and offerings.
- Diverse Inventory: Like Fellows.co.uk, many auction houses offer a wide range of goods, from fine art and antiques to jewellery and collectables. This broad approach is common.
- Online Bidding Capabilities: The shift to online platforms is widespread, with most major auctioneers offering live online bidding and comprehensive digital catalogues.
- Buyer’s Premium Model: The charging of a buyer’s premium as a percentage of the hammer price is an industry standard.
- Physical Presence: Many retain physical viewing rooms and auction salerooms alongside their online operations.
- Valuation Services: Free or paid valuation services are a standard offering for potential sellers.
Differences and Ethical Considerations
The differences often lie in specialisation, scale, and importantly, the specific categories of items they choose to handle.
- Specialisation: Some auction houses specialise exclusively in one or two categories (e.g., only fine art, or only stamps), which can make them more expert in that niche but also limit their general appeal. Fellows.co.uk, by contrast, is very generalist.
- Scale: Larger international auctioneers (e.g., Sotheby’s, Christie’s) operate on a much grander scale, handling multi-million-pound sales and a global clientele. Fellows.co.uk is a significant UK regional player.
- Ethical Stance: While many auction houses deal in alcohol or sometimes provide ancillary pawnbroking services through affiliated entities, the explicit direct offering of ‘Pawnbroking’ and ‘Wine & Spirits’ departments on Fellows.co.uk is a clear and direct ethical challenge. Other houses might have more nuanced offerings or fewer direct links to problematic services. When evaluating any auction house, the presence of problematic categories (like alcohol or interest-based finance) is the primary ethical filter.
How to Cancel Fellows.co.uk Account or Lot Alerts
For those who have created an account or set up lot alerts on Fellows.co.uk and wish to discontinue their association, the process typically involves managing account settings. While there is no explicit “Cancel Subscription” option mentioned for services, managing account preferences and alerts is usually straightforward.
Managing Lot Alerts and Email Preferences
Fellows.co.uk offers direct control over notifications.
- Accessing ‘My Fellows Account’: Users can log into their ‘My Fellows Account’ to manage their preferences. This is the central hub for user settings.
- Keyword Alerts: Within the account, there should be an option to view, modify, or delete existing keyword alerts. This would stop notifications for specific items.
- Newsletter Preferences: The newsletter signup form indicates options to “Subscribe to all auctions” or select specific interests. Users should be able to update these preferences within their account settings to reduce or stop email communications. There is also an option to “Skip This Step” during sign-up, or to unsubscribe from the newsletter if an unsubscribe link is provided in the emails themselves.
Deleting Your Account
While a direct “delete account” button might not be immediately visible, contacting customer support is usually the most effective way to fully close an account. Amysgifts.co.uk Review
- Contacting Customer Support: Users should contact Fellows.co.uk directly via their provided phone numbers (+44 121 212 2131 or +44 20 7127 4198) or their ‘Contact Us’ email form. Clearly state the request to have the account fully deleted.
- Data Protection: Under UK data protection regulations (GDPR), individuals have the right to request the erasure of their personal data. Fellows.co.uk’s privacy policy (linked on their site) should outline their data retention practices and how users can exercise their rights. It’s prudent to refer to this policy for specific instructions on data deletion requests.
FAQ
What is Fellows.co.uk?
Fellows.co.uk is an established UK auction house, founded in 1876, that facilitates the buying and selling of a wide range of items, including watches, jewellery, fine art, antiques, and collectables, through online and physical auctions.
Is Fellows.co.uk a legitimate company?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk is a legitimate and long-established company, operating as an auction house in the United Kingdom since 1876 with physical locations in Birmingham and London.
What types of items does Fellows.co.uk auction?
Fellows.co.uk auctions a diverse range of items across various departments, including Clocks & Barometers, Coins & Banknotes, Decorative Art, Fine Art, Furniture, Handbags, Jewellery, Medals, Photography, Silver & Plated Ware, Stamps, Toys, Dolls & Gaming, Watches, and Wine & Spirits, among others.
Are there ethical concerns with Fellows.co.uk?
Yes, significant ethical concerns arise from their explicit inclusion of ‘Pawnbroking’ (involving interest) and ‘Wine & Spirits’ (involving alcohol) departments, both of which are forbidden. The general nature of auctions can also involve elements of speculation and excessive uncertainty (gharar).
Can I get a free valuation from Fellows.co.uk?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk offers free valuations for items you might wish to sell through their auction house. You can usually start this process via their website. Micro-scooters.co.uk Review
How do I bid in a Fellows.co.uk auction?
You can bid in Fellows.co.uk auctions through several methods: live online bidding via their “Fellows LIVE NOW” platform, leaving commission bids, or arranging telephone bids for specific lots.
Does Fellows.co.uk offer international shipping?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk states that their in-house shipping services and state-of-the-art bidding technology have expanded their reach globally, allowing them to cater to an international clientele.
What is a Buyer’s Premium at Fellows.co.uk?
A Buyer’s Premium is an additional percentage charge added to the hammer price (the winning bid) that the buyer must pay to the auction house. This is standard practice in the auction industry.
How can I get updates on specific items from Fellows.co.uk?
You can set up “personalised keyword alerts” on Fellows.co.uk through your ‘My Fellows Account’. This feature notifies you when new catalogues go live with items matching your specified interests.
Where are Fellows.co.uk’s physical locations?
Fellows.co.uk has auction rooms located in Birmingham’s Jewellery Quarter (19 Augusta Street, Birmingham, B18 6JA) and valuation and viewing facilities in Mayfair, London (29 Charles Street, London, W1J 5DT). Penguinrecruitment.co.uk Review
Does Fellows.co.uk have a customer service contact number?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk provides contact numbers for both their Birmingham office (+44 121 212 2131) and London office (+44 20 7127 4198).
Can I view past auction results on Fellows.co.uk?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk provides an ‘Auction Results’ or ‘Archive Auctions’ section on their website where you can view historical results from previous sales.
What are the payment options for winning bids on Fellows.co.uk?
The website indicates a “MAKE A PAYMENT” link, suggesting various online payment methods are available. Specific details on acceptable payment types (e.g., bank transfer, card payments) would typically be found in their terms and conditions or buyer information.
Is Pawnbroking directly offered by Fellows.co.uk?
Yes, the Fellows.co.uk website explicitly lists ‘Pawnbroking’ as one of its departments, indicating it offers these services directly. This is a primary ethical concern.
Does Fellows.co.uk deal in alcohol?
Yes, Fellows.co.uk lists ‘Wine & Spirits’ as one of its auction departments, meaning it facilitates the sale of alcoholic beverages. This is also a primary ethical concern. Addictionmotorsport.co.uk Review
How do I close my Fellows.co.uk account?
To close your Fellows.co.uk account, you typically need to contact their customer support directly via phone or email, requesting account deletion. Under UK data protection laws, you have the right to request erasure of your data.
Are there any subscription fees for using Fellows.co.uk?
While there isn’t a stated subscription fee to simply browse or create an account, buyers pay a ‘Buyer’s Premium’ on top of the hammer price for successful bids, and sellers pay various commissions and fees.
What kind of information is available in the Fellows.co.uk blog?
The Fellows.co.uk blog contains articles related to various departments, offering insights into the history of certain items, artist profiles, industry news, and guides related to collecting or specific categories.
Can I sell items other than luxury goods through Fellows.co.uk?
While Fellows.co.uk is known for luxury items like watches and jewellery, their departments also include categories like ‘Advertising & Ephemera’, ‘Coins & Banknotes’, ‘Stamps & Philately’, and ‘Toys, Dolls & Gaming’, suggesting a broader range of collectables are accepted.
What is the ‘My Fellows Account’ feature for?
The ‘My Fellows Account’ allows users to manage their bids, create a wishlist, view archives of previous auction results, manage invoices, set email alert preferences, and more, centralising their activity on the platform. Sealinetaxicab.co.uk Review
Leave a Reply