Wesharebonds.com Review

Based on looking at the website, Wesharebonds.com presents itself as a platform for crowdfunding real estate and SME investments. However, for those seeking ethical financial dealings, particularly within an Islamic framework, Wesharebonds.com is not recommended. The core offering involves interest-based returns rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%* and investment structures that inherently carry elements of riba interest, which is strictly prohibited in Islam. Furthermore, the website explicitly states that investments are not covered by deposit guarantee or investor compensation schemes, highlighting a significant risk of capital loss. While the platform boasts professional selection and co-investment, the fundamental nature of its financial instruments renders it unsuitable for individuals adhering to Shariah principles.

Overall Review Summary:

• Website Focus: Crowdfunding for real estate and SME projects.
• Investment Model: Offers “rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%” on investments.
• Risk Disclosure: Explicitly warns of total capital loss and no deposit/investor compensation coverage.
• Ethical Stance Islamic: Not Recommended due to inherent interest riba in its investment model.
• Account Creation Status: Currently not accepting new investor accounts.
• Transparency: Provides links to regulatory information and risk disclosures.
• Co-investment: Claims to have shareholders and team co-investing in projects.
• Minimum Investment: €1,000.

Engaging in interest-based transactions, like those offered by WeShareBonds, is a grave matter in Islam, leading to severe consequences both in this life and the Hereafter.

The pursuit of wealth through impermissible means, such as riba, undermines the very essence of ethical financial conduct and can lead to societal imbalance and injustice.

It is a path that ultimately brings about a negative outcome, lacking divine blessing and causing spiritual harm.

0.0 0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews) Excellent0% Very good0% Average0% Poor0% Terrible0% There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. Your review Your overall rating Select a Rating5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star Title of your review Your review Your name Your email This review is based on my own experience and is my genuine opinion. ​ Submit Review

Amazon.com: Check Amazon for Wesharebonds.com Review Latest Discussions & Reviews:

Instead, a Muslim should always seek alternative avenues that align with the principles of justice, equity, and permissible earnings.

Best Alternatives for Ethical Investment and Wealth Management:

• Amanah Ventures
  • Key Features: Focuses on Shariah-compliant venture capital and private equity investments. Offers opportunities in technology startups and growing businesses.
  • Price: Investment amounts vary based on opportunity.
  • Pros: Strict adherence to Islamic finance principles, high growth potential in ethical sectors, diversified portfolio options.
  • Cons: Higher risk associated with venture investments, illiquidity.
• Wahed Invest
  • Key Features: A global Shariah-compliant digital investment platform. Offers diversified portfolios in stocks, sukuk, and gold, screened for ethical compliance.
  • Price: Varies based on investment amount and service tier. typically low fees.
  • Pros: Easy-to-use platform, automatic rebalancing, accessible for various investment sizes, fully Shariah-compliant.
  • Cons: Limited direct control over specific asset selection, digital-only interaction.
• Lariba
  • Key Features: Offers Shariah-compliant home financing and business financing based on ethical trade principles e.g., Murabaha, Musharakah, avoiding conventional interest.
  • Price: Specific financing rates depend on the product and market conditions.
  • Pros: Provides a vital service homeownership without interest, transparent structure, experienced in Islamic finance.
  • Cons: May have stricter qualification criteria than conventional lenders, limited to specific types of financing.
• Zoya App
  • Key Features: Not an investment platform itself, but a powerful tool for screening stocks for Shariah compliance. Helps investors build their own ethical portfolios.
  • Price: Free basic version, premium subscription for advanced features.
  • Pros: Empowers individuals to make informed Shariah-compliant investment decisions, comprehensive screening criteria, user-friendly interface.
  • Cons: Requires users to manage their own brokerage accounts, not an investment platform.
• Saturna Capital
  • Key Features: Manages the Amana Funds, which are globally recognized Shariah-compliant mutual funds investing in ethical companies.
  • Price: Standard mutual fund expense ratios apply.
  • Pros: Professionally managed, diversified portfolios, long track record of Shariah compliance, suitable for long-term growth.
  • Cons: Fund performance can fluctuate with market conditions, management fees.
• Islamic Relief USA For Philanthropic Investment
  • Key Features: While not an investment platform for personal returns, it represents an ethical avenue for wealth utilization through charity sadaqah and zakat, investing in humanitarian projects globally.
  • Price: Donation-based.
  • Pros: Direct impact on communities, aligns with Islamic principles of wealth distribution, clear reporting on projects.
  • Cons: No financial returns for the donor, purely philanthropic.
• Purely Ethical Gold & Silver For tangible asset investment
  • Key Features: Investing in physical gold and silver bullion can be a Shariah-compliant way to preserve wealth, provided the transaction involves immediate possession and avoids interest-based financing.
  • Price: Market price of gold/silver + dealer premium.
  • Pros: Tangible asset, hedge against inflation, permissible in Islam under specific conditions.
  • Cons: Storage costs, price volatility, not income-generating in itself.

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

Wesharebonds.com Review & First Look

When you first land on Wesharebonds.com, the immediate impression is one of a professional and well-structured financial platform.

The site’s interface is clean, modern, and primarily in French, which is a key indicator of its primary target market—France and potentially the broader European Union given its regulatory claims.

The initial messaging emphasizes creating an account to “Finance useful projects, carried by responsible and high-performing entrepreneurs,” focusing on real estate and SME investments.

This immediately positions it as a crowdfunding and crowdlending platform.

Website Design and User Experience

The aesthetic is straightforward, utilizing a minimalist color palette that emphasizes clarity and professionalism. Airportchauffeurslondon.com Review

Navigation is intuitive, with clear calls to action such as “Créez votre compte” Create your account and “Télécharger notre guide” Download our guide. The layout prioritizes essential information, including investment opportunities, key benefits, and regulatory assurances.

• Clean Layout: The use of white space and a clear font makes the text easily readable.
• Intuitive Navigation: Menus are logically organized, allowing users to quickly find information about different investment types e.g., real estate, SMEs, regulatory details, and contact information.
• Responsive Design: The website appears to adapt well to different screen sizes, suggesting a mobile-friendly approach, which is crucial for modern users accessing information on various devices.

Initial Impressions of Legitimacy

Wesharebonds.com attempts to build trust by highlighting its regulatory compliance.

It states, “Plateforme régulée par l’AMF” Platform regulated by the AMF, referring to the Autorité des marchés financiers, the French financial markets regulator.

This is a crucial piece of information for any financial platform, as regulation provides a layer of oversight and consumer protection.

They also mention being “agréée en tant que Prestataire de Services de Financement Participatif PSFP sous le numéro FP-2023-6,” which is a specific European crowdfunding service provider license. Jomclassifieds.com Review

• Regulatory Claims: The explicit mention of AMF regulation and a PSFP license FP-2023-6 lends a significant degree of credibility. This suggests the platform operates within a legal framework, subjecting it to certain compliance requirements.
• Partnerships Mentioned: The website highlights partnerships and involvement with reputable entities like “La Banque Postale” a major French bank and “La Mutuelle Générale,” stating that these institutions have invested alongside their members. This can instill confidence in potential investors.
• Transparency of Information: The site provides links to external documents, such as the relevant EU directives 2014/49/UE and 97/9/CE regarding deposit guarantee and investor compensation schemes, and a dedicated page to “En savoir plus sur les risques” Learn more about the risks. This proactive disclosure of risks is a positive sign of transparency.

Wesharebonds.com Pros & Cons Islamic Perspective

From an Islamic finance perspective, the fundamental structure of Wesharebonds.com presents significant challenges, primarily centered around the concept of riba interest. While the platform might appear attractive with its stated returns and professional backing, its underlying financial mechanisms are problematic for a Muslim investor. Therefore, for this section, we will focus on the “Cons” as they relate directly to Islamic principles, highlighting why such a platform is generally not recommended.

Major Cons from an Islamic Perspective

The primary and most critical concern with Wesharebonds.com, for a Muslim, is its reliance on interest-based returns. The website prominently advertises “Rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%*,” which translates to annual returns of up to 10%. This phrasing, common in conventional finance, directly implies a fixed or anticipated return on capital, which is the very definition of riba.

• Riba Interest: Islam strictly prohibits riba in all its forms. This includes both the taking and giving of interest. Investments that guarantee or project a fixed percentage return on capital, without direct participation in profit and loss sharing or a permissible underlying asset-backed transaction like Murabaha or Ijara, structured correctly, fall under the category of riba. WeShareBonds’ model, focused on “rendements” on invested capital in PME and real estate, suggests a debt-based financing model or a structure that extracts a fixed return, rather than a genuine profit-sharing partnership.
  • Prohibition: The Quran explicitly condemns riba, equating it to warring against Allah and His Messenger. The Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him also cursed those who deal with riba, including the one who consumes it, the one who gives it, the one who writes it, and the two who witness it.
  • Lack of Risk Sharing: True Islamic finance emphasizes risk sharing. In permissible investment like Musharakah or Mudarabah, both the investor and the entrepreneur share in the profits and losses. If the project incurs a loss, the investor also bears a portion of that loss, not just the entrepreneur. The “rendements” advertised by WeShareBonds do not indicate this inherent risk-sharing, suggesting a debt-based or interest-bearing arrangement.
• Uncertainty Gharar: While the platform provides warnings about potential capital loss, the structure of projected “rendements” can still introduce elements of gharar excessive uncertainty or deception if the underlying contracts are not transparent and free from speculative elements. While some level of risk is inherent in any investment, Islam prohibits transactions where the outcome is excessively ambiguous or the nature of the transaction is unclear.
  • Risk of Loss: The explicit disclaimer, “Un investissement dans un projet de financement participatif comporte le risque de perte totale du capital investi et nécessite une immobilisation de votre épargne,” while transparent, underscores the inherent risk. For a Muslim, bearing risk is permissible as long as the underlying transaction is Shariah-compliant and free from riba and excessive gharar. However, pairing this risk with interest-based returns makes the entire proposition impermissible.

Missing Shariah Compliance Features

A legitimate Shariah-compliant investment platform would typically highlight specific features to assure adherence to Islamic principles. These are conspicuously absent on WeShareBonds.

• Shariah Board/Advisory: There is no mention of a Shariah supervisory board or independent Shariah advisors who vet and approve the platform’s financial instruments and operations. This is a standard requirement for any Islamic financial institution.
• Permissible Asset Screening: For real estate or SME investments, a Shariah-compliant platform would detail how it screens projects to ensure they are involved in permissible activities e.g., not financing businesses dealing in alcohol, pork, gambling, or conventional finance. WeShareBonds does not provide any information regarding the nature of the businesses or real estate projects they finance beyond being “useful.”
• Clean Accounting and Purification: Islamic finance platforms often discuss mechanisms for purifying impermissible income e.g., from conventional interest earned on liquidity management, if any, before distributing returns to investors. No such mechanism is mentioned.

In conclusion, despite its professional appearance and regulatory claims, Wesharebonds.com’s model fundamentally clashes with Islamic finance principles due to its reliance on interest-based returns.

For Muslims, engaging with such a platform would be considered impermissible, regardless of the potential for financial gain. Ilovebutterfly.net Review

Wesharebonds.com Alternatives

Given the issues with Wesharebonds.com from an Islamic finance perspective, it’s crucial to explore alternatives that align with Shariah principles.

These alternatives focus on ethical investments, genuine profit-and-loss sharing, and avoiding interest-based transactions.

Halal Investment Platforms & Services

Instead of platforms that offer fixed “rendements” which often imply interest, look for those that emphasize profit-and-loss sharing, asset-backed financing, or ethical equity investments.

*   Overview: Focuses on venture capital and private equity investments in Shariah-compliant businesses. This means investing in startups and growth-stage companies that adhere to Islamic ethical guidelines, sharing in their actual profits and losses.
*   Why it's an alternative: Provides exposure to high-growth sectors while maintaining strict adherence to Islamic finance principles, avoiding *riba* entirely.
*   Key Features: Direct equity investments, due diligence on Shariah compliance of target companies, potential for significant returns tied to business success.
*   Overview: A global digital investment platform offering diversified portfolios of Shariah-compliant stocks, sukuk Islamic bonds, and gold. Their investment methodology is rigorously screened by a Shariah board.
*   Why it's an alternative: Offers a straightforward way to invest in a diversified, Shariah-compliant portfolio without individual stock picking. Accessible for various investment levels.
*   Key Features: Automated portfolio management, regular Shariah screening, low fees, accessible via mobile app.
*   Overview: Specializes in Shariah-compliant home and business financing. Instead of interest-based loans, they use models like Murabaha cost-plus financing or Musharakah partnership to facilitate asset acquisition without violating Islamic principles.
*   Why it's an alternative: Addresses critical financial needs like homeownership in a permissible manner, avoiding conventional mortgage interest.
*   Key Features: Asset-backed financing, clear contracts, focus on ethical business practices.

• Saturna Capital Amana Funds
  • Overview: Manages a family of globally diversified Shariah-compliant mutual funds. These funds invest in companies whose activities and financial ratios meet strict Islamic ethical criteria.
  • Why it’s an alternative: Offers professionally managed, diversified portfolios that have been rigorously screened for Shariah compliance by a dedicated Shariah advisory board.
  • Key Features: Diversification across sectors and geographies, long track record, transparent Shariah screening process.
  • Overview: While not an investment platform itself, Zoya is an essential tool for Muslim investors. It allows users to screen individual stocks for Shariah compliance, helping them build their own permissible investment portfolios through conventional brokerage accounts.
  • Why it’s an alternative: Empowers individuals to make informed Shariah-compliant investment decisions without relying on a dedicated Islamic fund, offering greater control over asset selection.
  • Key Features: Detailed Shariah compliance reports for stocks, financial ratio analysis, halal stock screener.

Ethical Crowdfunding and Microfinance

For those interested in supporting projects or small businesses, look for platforms that clearly state their adherence to ethical financing principles, typically focusing on profit-and-loss sharing or charitable models rather than interest.

• Kiva
  • Overview: A non-profit organization that allows individuals to lend small amounts of money microloans to entrepreneurs and students in underserved communities worldwide. While Kiva itself is not Shariah-compliant by default, it offers a “Friends of Kiva” option where you can specifically choose to fund loans that do not charge interest to the borrowers. This allows for a charitable, interest-free lending experience.
  • Why it’s an alternative: Allows individuals to support real-world projects and businesses in a way that can be structured to avoid interest for the lender, aligning with the spirit of Islamic charity and social impact.
  • Key Features: Direct impact, low minimum loan amounts $25, high repayment rates, focus on poverty alleviation.
• Islamic Relief USA Zakat & Sadaqah
  • Overview: While not an investment for personal financial return, donating through Islamic Relief or similar reputable Islamic charities allows wealth to be invested in humanitarian and development projects globally, aligning with the highest forms of Islamic financial ethics Zakat and Sadaqah. This is an investment in the Hereafter and community development.
  • Why it’s an alternative: Redirects funds from impermissible investments to truly ethical and impactful causes, fulfilling religious obligations and earning spiritual rewards.
  • Key Features: Focus on poverty alleviation, emergency aid, sustainable development, clear reporting on fund utilization.

These alternatives provide various pathways for individuals to manage their wealth and engage in financial activities in a manner consistent with Islamic principles, avoiding the pitfalls of interest-based transactions. Dmlcomputerrepair.com Review

How to Avoid Impermissible Financial Transactions

However, with clear understanding and diligent effort, it’s entirely possible to conduct your financial affairs in a permissible manner.

The key is to recognize the fundamental elements that render a transaction impermissible and actively seek alternatives.

Understanding Riba Interest and Gharar Uncertainty

The two primary forbidden elements in Islamic finance are riba interest and gharar excessive uncertainty or speculation. Understanding these is your first line of defense.

• Riba: This isn’t just about borrowing money from a bank and paying interest. Riba encompasses any predetermined increase over the principal in a loan or debt transaction, or any exchange of unequal amounts of the same type of currency/commodity with delay.
  • Examples to Avoid:
    • Conventional Loans: Mortgage, car loans, personal loans from conventional banks that charge interest.
    • Credit Cards: Using credit cards in a way that incurs interest charges.
    • Bonds: Conventional bonds that pay a fixed interest rate coupon.
    • Interest-bearing Savings Accounts: Any account where your deposit earns a fixed, guaranteed percentage return.
  • Core Principle: Islam encourages shared risk and rewards tied to tangible economic activity, not guaranteed returns on mere capital.
• Gharar: This refers to transactions with excessive ambiguity, uncertainty, or speculative elements that could lead to unfairness or exploitation.
  * Speculative Derivatives: Financial instruments whose value is derived from an underlying asset, often involving high speculation and detachment from real assets.
  * Gambling and Lotteries: Explicitly prohibited due to their speculative nature and reliance on pure chance.
  * Some Insurance: Conventional insurance where the terms are unclear or involve excessive gharar though Takaful, Islamic insurance, is permissible.
  • Core Principle: Transactions should be clear, transparent, and fair, with outcomes reasonably predictable based on effort and market forces, not pure chance.

Due Diligence on Financial Products and Services

Before engaging with any financial product or service, rigorous due diligence is paramount, especially when it comes to Shariah compliance. Don’t rely solely on marketing claims. Guzzburystudio.com Review

• Look for a Shariah Supervisory Board SSB: Reputable Islamic financial institutions will have a dedicated SSB comprising qualified Islamic scholars who review and approve all products, services, and operations for Shariah compliance. Check their credentials and the transparency of their rulings.
• Understand the Underlying Contracts: Don’t just look at the headline “return.” Dive into the actual contractual agreements.
  • Is it a loan with interest? Impermissible
  • Is it a partnership Musharakah or Mudarabah where profit and loss are genuinely shared? Permissible
  • Is it a trade-based transaction Murabaha, Ijara where an asset is genuinely bought and sold or leased? Permissible, if structured correctly
• Screen the Investment Activities: If investing in funds or platforms, ensure that the underlying businesses or projects are engaged in permissible activities. This means avoiding companies involved in:
  • Alcohol, tobacco, gambling, pornography, conventional banking/insurance, pork products, weapons manufacturing in certain contexts.
• Check Financial Ratios for equity investments: For investing in stocks, a common method is to screen companies based on their financial ratios e.g., debt-to-equity, cash and interest-bearing securities-to-assets. This helps ensure the company’s reliance on interest-based debt or impermissible income is minimal. Tools like Zoya App can assist here.
• Avoid Deceptive Schemes: Be wary of anything that promises abnormally high, guaranteed returns with little to no risk. These are often indicators of fraudulent or impermissible schemes.

Seeking Knowledge and Expert Advice

The best defense is a well-informed offense.

Continuously educate yourself on Islamic finance principles.

• Read Reputable Sources: Engage with scholarly articles, books, and reputable websites on Islamic finance. Organizations like the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions AAOIFI provide comprehensive Shariah standards.
• Consult Scholars: If uncertain about a specific transaction or product, consult a qualified Islamic scholar specializing in finance. Their guidance can save you from inadvertently engaging in impermissible activities.
• Join Ethical Investment Communities: Engage with online forums or local communities focused on Islamic finance. Sharing knowledge and experiences can be invaluable.

By diligently applying these principles, individuals can navigate the complex financial world, ensuring their transactions remain within the boundaries of what is permissible and blessed.

Wesharebonds.com Pricing & Investment Structure

Understanding the pricing and investment structure of a platform like Wesharebonds.com is crucial for any potential investor, and especially so for those scrutinizing it through an Islamic finance lens.

The website outlines several key financial parameters that define how users engage with the platform and what returns they might expect. Beltbuy.com Review

Investment Thresholds and Returns

Wesharebonds.com clearly communicates its minimum investment requirement and the potential annual returns.

• Minimum Investment: The platform states “Investissement dès 1.000€” Investment from €1,000. This sets an accessible entry point for a broad range of private investors, making crowdfunding a viable option for those with moderate savings.
• Annual Returns: They advertise “Rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%” Annual returns up to 10%. This is a significant figure in the current low-interest rate environment and is likely a major draw for investors. However, it’s crucial to note the asterisk, which points to a disclaimer regarding risks. From an Islamic perspective, this “rendement” or guaranteed return structure is highly problematic as it implies riba interest, which is strictly forbidden.
  • Industry Benchmarks: For context, typical savings accounts in Europe currently offer well under 1% interest. Conventional stock market returns historically average around 7-10% annually over long periods, but these are not guaranteed and come with significant volatility. A guaranteed return of up to 10% on a fixed-term investment, even if not fully guaranteed but “targeted,” would usually signal a debt-based instrument.

Investment Duration and Liquidity

The platform provides a clear indication of how long investments are typically held.

• Investment Duration: “Durée d’investissement entre 1 mois et 5 ans” Investment duration between 1 month and 5 years. This range suggests flexibility, allowing investors to choose projects based on their liquidity needs. Shorter durations could be attractive for those who prefer quicker access to their capital, while longer terms might offer higher “rendements.”
  • Illiquidity Warning: The disclaimer, “nécessite une immobilisation de votre épargne” requires immobilization of your savings, is an important warning about the illiquidity of these investments. Unlike publicly traded stocks or readily accessible savings accounts, funds invested in crowdfunding projects are typically locked in until the project’s completion or the loan’s repayment.

Co-investment and Risk Sharing Conventional View

Wesharebonds.com emphasizes its co-investment model as a sign of confidence and alignment of interests.

• Co-investment: “Co-investissement de nos actionnaires et de notre équipe” Co-investment from our shareholders and our team is highlighted. This implies that the platform’s insiders invest their own capital alongside the crowd, theoretically ensuring rigorous project selection.
  • Alignment of Interests: This strategy is often employed in crowdfunding to reassure investors that the platform has skin in the game. If the platform’s team is also investing, they are incentivized to select high-quality projects.
  • Risk Mitigation Conventional: While this may conventionally be seen as a positive sign of shared risk and commitment, it does not alter the fundamental Shariah impermissibility if the underlying transaction is interest-based. In Islamic finance, genuine profit-and-loss sharing means both parties bear the risk of loss, not just the potential for lower “rendements” if the project underperforms. If the “co-investment” is also based on riba, it does not make it permissible.

Regulatory Disclaimers and Warnings

The platform includes several critical disclaimers about the risks involved, which are standard for regulated financial services but particularly important for crowdfunding.

• Avertissement: “Les rendements proposés doivent toujours être évalués au regard des risques associés. Un investissement dans un projet de financement participatif comporte le risque de perte totale du capital investi et nécessite une immobilisation de votre épargne. Il n’est ni couvert par le système de garantie des dépôts directive 2014/49/UE ni par le système d’indemnisation des investisseurs directive 97/9/CE.”
  • Key Warnings:
    • Total Capital Loss: Explicitly warns of the risk of losing the entire invested capital. This is a common and significant risk in unlisted private equity and debt, characteristic of crowdfunding.
    • No Deposit/Investor Guarantees: Crucially, it states that investments are not covered by deposit guarantee schemes like those protecting bank deposits up to a certain amount, e.g., €100,000 in the EU or investor compensation schemes which protect investors in case a financial institution fails. This means if the project or platform fails, investors could lose everything without recourse to state-backed compensation.
    • Past Performance: “Les performances passées ne préjugent pas des performances futures.” Past performance does not guarantee future performance. This is a standard and necessary disclaimer in any investment context.

In summary, while Wesharebonds.com offers an accessible entry point and potentially high returns, its pricing and structure, particularly the explicit mention of “rendements,” strongly indicate an interest-based model. Jixhost.com Review

This, combined with the significant risk of total capital loss and lack of guarantees, makes it an unsuitable and impermissible option for a Muslim investor.

Ethical Considerations for Real Estate & SME Investments

When considering investments in real estate and Small and Medium-sized Enterprises SMEs, ethical considerations extend beyond just financial returns. For those guided by Islamic principles, these considerations become paramount, dictating not only how one invests but also what one invests in.

Permissibility of the Underlying Business/Asset

A crucial ethical filter in Islamic finance is the nature of the business or asset being financed.

Even if the investment structure itself were seemingly non-interest-based which is not the case with WeShareBonds’ “rendements”, the underlying activity must be permissible.

• Real Estate:
  • Permissible Use: Investing in real estate is generally permissible in Islam as it involves a tangible asset. However, the use of the property is critical. Is it being developed for residential housing, offices, retail spaces, or industrial purposes? These are generally permissible.
  • Impermissible Use: Financing real estate projects that involve prohibited activities would make the investment impermissible. This includes:
    • Gambling establishments: Casinos, betting shops.
    • Alcohol production or distribution: Wineries, breweries, bars, liquor stores.
    • Pornography or immoral entertainment venues: Adult cinemas, nightclubs with illicit activities.
    • Conventional financial institutions: Buildings primarily used for interest-based banks or insurance companies.
  • Ethical Impact: Beyond permissibility, does the real estate project genuinely benefit the community? Does it contribute to sustainable development, affordable housing, or essential services? These are questions of positive societal impact that align with Islamic ethical values.
• SME Investments:
  • Nature of Business: Investing in SMEs requires careful scrutiny of their core business activities.
    • Permissible Businesses: Generally, businesses involved in manufacturing, retail of permissible goods, technology, services e.g., education, healthcare, logistics, agriculture, and sustainable energy are permissible.
    • Impermissible Businesses: Avoid businesses that:
      • Deal in haram forbidden products or services e.g., pork products, alcohol, tobacco, non-halal meat processing.
      • Are primarily involved in conventional financial services interest-based lending, conventional insurance.
      • Are involved in industries considered harmful or immoral e.g., adult entertainment, arms manufacturing of illicit weapons.
  • Ethical Conduct: Even for permissible businesses, their operational ethics matter. Do they treat employees fairly? Are their supply chains ethical? Do they engage in deceptive marketing? While difficult for a passive investor to ascertain fully, platforms committed to ethical investment might provide some transparency on these aspects.

Transparency and Accountability

Ethical investment demands transparency in how funds are used and accountability from those managing the investments. Otticafabbri.com Review

• Clear Disclosure: Investors should have clear information about the specific projects they are financing, including detailed business plans, financial projections, and the intended use of funds. Vague descriptions or “confidential projects” as seen on WeShareBonds can be a red flag if sufficient details are not provided after sign-up.
• Regular Reporting: Ethical platforms provide regular updates on the progress of projects and the financial performance of the underlying businesses. This allows investors to monitor their investments and ensures accountability from the entrepreneurs.
• Impact Reporting: Beyond financial returns, ethical investors often seek to understand the social or environmental impact of their investments. Platforms that provide clear metrics on job creation, environmental benefits, or community development are preferable.

Avoidance of Interest Riba in all Forms

As discussed, the most critical ethical barrier for Muslims is the pervasive nature of riba.

• Debt vs. Equity: True ethical investment in SMEs and real estate from an Islamic perspective primarily revolves around equity participation profit and loss sharing rather than debt with fixed interest.
  • Equity Musharakah/Mudarabah: In these models, the investor genuinely shares in the profits and bears the risk of loss alongside the entrepreneur. This aligns with the principle of shared risk and reward.
  • Permissible Debt Murabaha/Ijara: While these are debt-like, they are asset-backed and involve a legitimate trade or lease, not lending money for interest. For example, the financier buys the asset and then sells it to the entrepreneur at a marked-up price or leases it to them.
• WeShareBonds’ Model: The explicit mention of “rendements annuels” on WeShareBonds suggests a debt-based model where investors essentially lend money for a fixed return, which is tantamount to interest and thus impermissible in Islam, regardless of the underlying asset or SME.

In conclusion, while real estate and SME investments can be highly ethical and beneficial, rigorous due diligence is required to ensure both the structure of the investment avoiding riba and the nature of the underlying business align with Islamic principles.

Understanding the Risks of Crowdfunding Investment

Crowdfunding, while innovative, carries inherent risks that every potential investor must understand.

Wesharebonds.com, like other platforms in this space, explicitly highlights these risks, which is a positive sign of transparency.

However, transparency about risk doesn’t negate the risks themselves. Apexessays.com Review

For an ethical investor, understanding these layers of risk is crucial, particularly when combined with the impermissibility of the investment structure.

Risk of Total Capital Loss

The most significant risk in crowdfunding, especially in unlisted real estate and SME projects, is the potential for losing your entire invested capital.

• Project Failure: Businesses fail, and real estate projects encounter unforeseen problems. If the company you invested in goes bankrupt, or the property development stalls indefinitely, your investment could become worthless.
  • Statistics: While difficult to get exact figures for all crowdfunding projects, studies suggest a significant percentage of startups fail. For example, a 2019 report by Startup Genome indicated that 1 in 3 startups fail. Real estate projects can also be highly susceptible to market downturns, regulatory changes, or construction delays and cost overruns.
• No Guarantees: As Wesharebonds.com clearly states, “Il n’est ni couvert par le système de garantie des dépôts directive 2014/49/UE ni par le système d’indemnisation des investisseurs directive 97/9/CE.”
  • Deposit Guarantee Schemes DGS: These protect funds held in traditional bank accounts, typically up to €100,000 per depositor per bank in the EU. Crowdfunding investments are generally not considered deposits and are therefore not covered.
  • Investor Compensation Schemes ICS: These protect investors in case a regulated investment firm goes out of business and cannot return clients’ assets. While WeShareBonds is regulated, the ICS typically covers situations where the firm fails to hold assets properly, not where the underlying investment itself fails. The risk of the underlying project failing is borne by the investor.

Illiquidity Risk

Investing in crowdfunding projects often means your money is locked in for a specified period, ranging from months to several years.

• Long-term Commitment: Wesharebonds.com states durations between 1 month and 5 years, and explicitly mentions “nécessite une immobilisation de votre épargne” requires immobilization of your savings. This means you cannot easily withdraw your money before the project’s completion or the loan’s repayment.
• Lack of Secondary Market: Unlike publicly traded stocks, there is typically no active secondary market for crowdfunding investments. If you need cash urgently, you cannot simply sell your investment to another party. This lack of liquidity makes these investments unsuitable for funds you might need in the short to medium term.

Default Risk and Project Underperformance

Even if a project doesn’t completely fail, it might not perform as expected, leading to lower or no returns, or even partial capital loss.

• Loan Defaults: In crowdlending models, the borrower SME or real estate developer might default on their loan repayments. This can lead to delays in receiving your principal and “rendements,” or even non-recovery of a portion or all of your capital.
• Project Delays/Cost Overruns: Real estate projects are notoriously prone to delays and budget overruns. This can impact the project’s profitability and, consequently, the promised returns to investors.
• Valuation Challenges: Valuing unlisted businesses and real estate projects can be complex. The valuations presented by the platform might be optimistic, and the true value could be lower.

Platform Risk

While WeShareBonds is regulated, there is always a residual risk associated with the platform itself. Capfire.net Review

• Operational Failure: The platform could experience operational issues, cyberattacks, or even go out of business. While regulations aim to mitigate this, it’s a factor to consider.
• Due Diligence Quality: The quality of the platform’s due diligence on projects is paramount. If their selection process is flawed, investors are exposed to higher risks. WeShareBonds claims “Meilleure sélection de projets” and expertise, but this is their claim.

For ethical investors, these risks are compounded by the impermissibility of the interest-based structure.

Not only are you exposed to significant financial risks, but you are also engaging in a transaction that is forbidden, making the potential loss even more regrettable.

How to Conduct Ethical Due Diligence on Investment Opportunities

Conducting thorough due diligence is non-negotiable for any investor, but for those committed to Islamic principles, it takes on an added layer of importance. It’s not just about minimizing financial risk. it’s about ensuring the investment aligns with ethical and religious guidelines. Since Wesharebonds.com doesn’t meet the Shariah compliance criteria, this section will outline a comprehensive approach to ethical due diligence for any investment opportunity you consider.

1. Identify and Verify the Core Business Activity

The absolute first step is to understand what the business or project actually does.

• Permissible Sector: Does it operate in a sector permissible in Islam? Avoid businesses involved in alcohol, gambling, conventional finance interest-based loans, insurance, pork products, pornography, or weapons manufacturing.
  • Actionable Step: Read the company’s “About Us” page, mission statement, product descriptions, and investor presentations. Look for specific details on revenue streams and product offerings. For real estate, verify the intended use of the property.
• Value Proposition: Does the business offer genuine value to society? Does it solve a real problem or fulfill a genuine need? Ethical investments often have a positive societal impact beyond just financial gain.

2. Scrutinize the Financial Structure and Returns

This is where riba interest and gharar uncertainty are most likely to creep in. Weggeefhoek.net Review

• Avoid Fixed, Guaranteed Returns on Capital: If the investment promises a predetermined, fixed percentage return on your principal investment, it’s highly likely to be interest riba and thus impermissible. Phrases like “annual returns of X%” or “guaranteed yield” are major red flags.
  • Actionable Step: Look for models based on profit-and-loss sharing Musharakah, Mudarabah, where returns are tied to the actual performance of the business, or asset-backed transactions Murabaha, Ijara where a tangible asset is genuinely traded or leased.
• Debt Levels and Interest-Bearing Assets: Even if the direct investment is equity-based, the underlying company’s reliance on interest-based debt or holding of interest-bearing assets needs examination.
  • Actionable Step: For stock investments, use tools like Zoya App or manually check the company’s balance sheet for debt-to-equity ratios and the percentage of interest-bearing assets relative to total assets. Reputable Shariah standards like AAOIFI provide specific thresholds for these ratios.
• Transparency of Contracts: Demand clarity on the contractual terms. Is it a partnership agreement, a sales contract, or a loan agreement?
  • Actionable Step: Request and thoroughly read the investment contract. If it’s unclear or uses ambiguous financial jargon, seek expert advice.

3. Verify Shariah Compliance Oversight

For any platform or fund purporting to be Shariah-compliant, robust oversight is critical.

• Shariah Supervisory Board SSB: Does the platform or fund have an independent SSB?
  • Actionable Step: Identify the scholars on the SSB. Research their credentials and reputation in Islamic finance. Check if their rulings and reports are publicly available. A strong SSB is a hallmark of genuine Shariah compliance.
• Certification: Is the product or service certified by a recognized Shariah advisory body?
  • Actionable Step: Look for certifications from reputable organizations like AAOIFI or local Islamic finance bodies. However, always dig deeper to understand the basis of the certification.

4. Assess Regulatory Compliance and Risk Disclosures

Beyond ethical considerations, basic financial prudence is still necessary.

• Regulatory Status: Is the platform regulated by a recognized financial authority in its jurisdiction e.g., AMF in France, SEC in the US, FCA in the UK? Regulation offers a layer of oversight, though it doesn’t guarantee Shariah compliance.
  • Actionable Step: Verify their license number with the relevant regulatory body’s public register.
• Clear Risk Disclosures: Does the platform clearly articulate the risks involved, including the potential for capital loss, illiquidity, and lack of deposit/investor compensation schemes?
  • Actionable Step: Read all disclaimers and risk warnings carefully. Understand what happens if the project fails or the platform goes out of business.

5. Evaluate Management Team and Track Record

The people behind the investment are crucial.

• Experience and Expertise: Does the management team have relevant experience in the industry real estate, SME, finance?
  • Actionable Step: Review their professional backgrounds LinkedIn profiles, company bios. Look for a track record of successful ventures.
• Reputation: What is the general reputation of the company and its key individuals?
  • Actionable Step: Check online reviews e.g., Trustpilot, though exercise caution with unverified reviews, news articles, and any public complaints.

By meticulously following these steps, an ethical investor can significantly reduce the risk of engaging in impermissible transactions while making informed decisions about their investments.

It’s a journey of continuous learning and vigilance. Brillionaire.com Review

Wesharebonds.com vs. Conventional Crowdfunding Platforms

To truly understand Wesharebonds.com’s position, it’s helpful to compare it against other conventional crowdfunding platforms.

Similarities with Conventional Platforms

Wesharebonds.com shares many operational and structural similarities with typical crowdfunding platforms, particularly those focused on debt or equity investments in private markets.

• Investment Scope: Like many platforms, it focuses on unlisted assets, specifically real estate and SMEs. This is a common niche for platforms looking to provide alternative investment avenues beyond traditional stocks and bonds.
• Minimum Investment: The €1,000 minimum is comparable to many other crowdfunding platforms globally, which aim to make private investments accessible to a wider retail investor base, rather than solely institutional investors.
• Online Accessibility: The entirely online process for account opening and investment is standard for modern crowdfunding platforms, emphasizing convenience and speed.
• Risk Disclosures: The explicit warnings about potential capital loss, illiquidity, and lack of deposit/investor guarantees are boilerplate for this type of alternative investment. All responsible crowdfunding platforms should clearly state these risks.
• Co-investment Model: Many crowdfunding platforms or their managing entities co-invest alongside their users to demonstrate commitment and align interests. This is a common practice to build investor confidence.
• Regulatory Compliance: Being regulated by a financial authority AMF in France, PSFP license in EU is increasingly common and expected for legitimate crowdfunding platforms, providing a framework for investor protection and operational standards.

Differences and Specifics of Wesharebonds.com

While broadly similar, some specific aspects set Wesharebonds.com apart or are noteworthy.

• Focus on “Rendements”: While many debt crowdfunding platforms promise “yields” or “interest rates,” Wesharebonds.com’s consistent use of “rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%” explicitly points to an interest-bearing model. This is a clear indicator that differentiates it from platforms that might offer genuine equity crowdfunding sharing profits and losses, not just fixed returns.
• Geographic Focus: Its primary language French and regulatory body AMF clearly indicate a strong focus on the French and European markets, rather than a global reach often seen with larger platforms like Kickstarter which is for creative projects, not financial investments or Indiegogo.
• Current Account Creation Status: The notice “il n’est plus possible, pour le moment, de créer un compte investisseur sur WeShareBonds” is a significant operational difference. It suggests a pause in onboarding new investors, which could be due to various reasons regulatory changes, strategic shift, or capacity management. This differentiates it from platforms actively seeking new investors.
• Emphasis on “Club Deal” Projects: The mention of “Projet confidentiel – Ce projet est réservé à un cercle restreint d’investisseurs” for some opportunities suggests a tiered access model or private club deals, which might offer different terms or exclusivity. This is less common for entry-level crowdfunding where all projects are usually visible to all investors.
• Institutional Backing: The explicit mention of La Banque Postale and La Mutuelle Générale as shareholders and institutional investors is a strong differentiator. Not all crowdfunding platforms have such prominent institutional backing, which can be perceived as an added layer of credibility though again, it doesn’t change the Shariah impermissibility of the core offering.

In essence, Wesharebonds.com operates as a fairly standard, regulated crowdfunding platform specializing in debt-like investments in real estate and SMEs within the French market.

Its key differentiator from an Islamic perspective is its unambiguous interest-based return model, which renders it impermissible. 2baskets.com Review

From a conventional standpoint, its institutional backing and stated regulatory compliance are positives, but the general risks of crowdfunding illiquidity, capital loss remain.

FAQ

What is Wesharebonds.com?

Wesharebonds.com is a French crowdfunding platform that facilitates investments in real estate and Small and Medium-sized Enterprises SMEs, offering users the opportunity to finance projects with advertised annual returns.

Is Wesharebonds.com Shariah-compliant?

No, Wesharebonds.com is not Shariah-compliant.

Its investment model primarily relies on offering “rendements annuels” annual returns up to 10%, which indicates an interest-based riba structure, prohibited in Islam.

What kind of investments does Wesharebonds.com offer?

Wesharebonds.com primarily offers investment opportunities in real estate projects and SMEs through crowdfunding and crowdlending, allowing investors to fund these ventures. Kinzokusteel.com Review

What are the advertised returns on Wesharebonds.com?

Wesharebonds.com advertises “rendements annuels jusqu’à 10%,” implying potential annual returns of up to 10% on invested capital.

What is the minimum investment amount on Wesharebonds.com?

The minimum investment amount on Wesharebonds.com is €1,000.

How long are investments typically held on Wesharebonds.com?

Investments on Wesharebonds.com typically have a duration ranging from 1 month to 5 years.

Is my capital guaranteed on Wesharebonds.com?

No, Wesharebonds.com explicitly warns that investments carry the risk of total capital loss and are not covered by deposit guarantee schemes or investor compensation schemes.

Is Wesharebonds.com regulated?

Yes, Wesharebonds.com states it is regulated by the AMF Autorité des marchés financiers in France and holds a PSFP Prestataire de Services de Financement Participatif license under number FP-2023-6. Techlabmarket.com Review

Can I create a new investor account on Wesharebonds.com?

Based on the website’s homepage, it is currently not possible to create a new investor account on WeShareBonds “il n’est plus possible, pour le moment, de créer un compte investisseur sur WeShareBonds”.

What kind of risks are associated with Wesharebonds.com?

The risks include total capital loss, illiquidity money being locked in for the investment duration, project default risk, and general market risks.

Why is interest riba prohibited in Islam?

Interest riba is prohibited in Islam because it is seen as an exploitative practice that creates wealth without genuine economic activity or shared risk, leading to injustice and inequality.

What are ethical alternatives to Wesharebonds.com for Muslims?

Ethical alternatives include Shariah-compliant investment platforms like Wahed Invest, venture capital funds like Amanah Ventures, Islamic home financing providers like Lariba, and Shariah-compliant mutual funds like Amana Funds managed by Saturna Capital.

How can I ensure an investment is Shariah-compliant?

To ensure an investment is Shariah-compliant, look for platforms or funds with a Shariah Supervisory Board, understand the underlying contracts to ensure they are profit-and-loss sharing or asset-backed, and verify that the underlying business activities are permissible halal.

What is “Gharar” in Islamic finance?

“Gharar” refers to excessive uncertainty, ambiguity, or speculation in a contract that could lead to unfairness or dispute, and it is prohibited in Islamic finance.

Does Wesharebonds.com offer a free trial?

The website does not mention a “free trial” for investors.

Its model involves direct investment into projects.

How do I cancel a Wesharebonds.com subscription or investment?

The website does not explicitly detail a “subscription” or cancellation process.

Investments are typically locked in for their stated duration, and early withdrawal may not be possible.

Investors should consult their specific investment contracts.

What is the role of La Banque Postale with Wesharebonds.com?

La Banque Postale is stated to have entered Wesharebonds.com’s capital, holding 10%, indicating institutional backing and investment alongside other members.

Where can I find more information about the risks on Wesharebonds.com?

Wesharebonds.com provides a dedicated link “En savoir plus sur les risques” Learn more about the risks on its homepage for detailed information.

Does Wesharebonds.com offer a mobile app?

The website does not explicitly mention a dedicated mobile app, but it emphasizes online accessibility for account opening and investment, suggesting a mobile-friendly web experience.

What types of “Club Deal” projects are mentioned on Wesharebonds.com?

The website mentions “Club Deal” projects that are confidential and reserved for a restricted circle of investors, where the funds of WeShareBonds’ shareholders may not participate.