Romisaputra.com, upon initial examination, presents itself as a general information and news blog.
Its homepage is structured with various categories such as “Berita” (News), “Bisnis” (Business), “Edukasi” (Education), “Tekno” (Tech), “Game,” and “Tutorial.” The immediate impression is that of a typical blog providing diverse content.
However, a deeper dive reveals significant issues, particularly from an ethical standpoint and concerning the legitimacy of the information it offers.
The site’s content appears to be primarily in Indonesian, suggesting a target audience within Indonesia.
While the design is clean, the underlying structure and the topics covered raise serious questions about its suitability for a user seeking reliable and ethically sound information.
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. |
Amazon.com:
Check Amazon for Romisaputra.com Review & Latest Discussions & Reviews: |
Initial Impressions and Website Layout
The site’s layout is standard for a blog, with a clear navigation bar at the top, a main content area displaying recent articles, and a sidebar for popular posts or other widgets.
This conventional structure makes it easy to navigate through categories and find articles.
- Clean Interface: The design is minimalistic, which can be a pro for user experience, making content easy to read without too many distractions.
- Category Navigation: Prominently displayed categories allow users to filter content by interest, such as “Berita,” “Bisnis,” and “Tekno.”
- Recent Articles: The main section highlights the latest posts, ensuring users see fresh content upon arrival.
- Language Barrier: For non-Indonesian speakers, the content is largely inaccessible without translation tools, limiting its global appeal.
- Lack of Prominent Contact/About Info: Critical trust signals like easily identifiable “About Us” or “Contact Us” links are not immediately visible, which is a major red flag for any information portal.
Content Categories and Ethical Implications
The content categories themselves, while broad, include several that raise immediate ethical concerns from an Islamic perspective.
The most prominent are “Bisnis” (Business), which delves into stocks and gold, and “Crypto” (Cryptocurrency).
- “Emas Antam” and “Saham” (Gold and Stocks): The articles about “Harga Emas Antam di Pegadaian” (Antam Gold Price at Pawnshops) and “Rekomendasi Saham dan Pergerakan IHSG Hari Ini” (Stock Recommendations and IHSG Movement Today) are highly problematic. Traditional stock markets often involve interest-bearing transactions and companies that may not adhere to Sharia-compliant business practices. Engaging in interest (Riba) is strictly forbidden in Islam. Similarly, while physical gold is permissible, its trading through conventional financial instruments without actual possession or involving interest can become problematic.
- “Crypto” (Cryptocurrency): The article “Harga Kripto Hari Ini, Kamis 12 Juni 2025, Harga Bitcoin dan Solana di $107.889” directly promotes cryptocurrency. The vast majority of cryptocurrencies are highly speculative, lack tangible underlying assets, and are often subject to extreme volatility and manipulation. Many Islamic scholars view them as impermissible due to elements of Maysir (gambling) and Gharar (excessive uncertainty), and some are used in transactions that are not permissible.
- “Game” and “Anime”: While not inherently forbidden, content in these categories can easily lead to entertainment that promotes immoral behavior, violence, or themes contrary to Islamic values. Without clear content moderation or filters, it becomes a risky area for a Muslim audience.
- General Tutorials and Services: Categories like “Jasa Bubut CNC” (CNC Lathe Services) or general tutorials on BNSP certification are generally permissible, but their presence within a site promoting problematic financial topics can lend an undue sense of legitimacy to the whole platform.
Information Quality and Credibility
Beyond the ethical issues, the quality and credibility of the information presented on Romisaputra.com are questionable. Uniformsbyniki.com Review
The reliance on what appear to be generic news aggregations and the peculiar use of future dates in article titles detract from its trustworthiness.
- Future-Dated Articles: Articles titled “Kamis 12 Juni 2025” for current news raise a significant red flag. This suggests either a lack of real-time content updates, an automated content generation system that might be flawed, or a deliberate attempt to appear current when the content might be pre-scheduled or speculative. This undermines the credibility of the “news” aspect entirely.
- Lack of Authoritative Sources: The articles often refer to general sources like “Google Finansial” or “Coinmarketcap” for data, which are aggregators, but there’s no evident original research, expert commentary, or deep analytical insight. This positions the site as a mere repeater of information rather than an authority.
- No Editorial Team or Experts: There is no visible information about the authors, editors, or the team behind Romisaputra.com. This anonymity prevents users from assessing the expertise or bias of the content creators. Credible news and information sites always have an “About Us” section detailing their team and mission.
Leave a Reply