The Ethical Quandaries of “Earned Media” & Paid Link Building

Distinguishing Genuine Earned Media from Influenced Placements

The Islamic Perspective on Gharar in Business Contracts

Gharar, or excessive uncertainty, is forbidden in Islamic financial and business transactions. A contract should have clear deliverables and measurable outcomes. When Nostringspublicrelations.com offers “PR Packages” with the explicit disclaimer “Coverage not guaranteed — but we hustle hard,” it introduces significant gharar. A client pays a monthly fee (£249) for “PR activity,” but there is no assurance of the primary desired outcome: media coverage. This is akin to buying a product that might or might not materialize. While some level of risk is inherent in all ventures, gharar arises when the uncertainty is so great that it undermines the fundamental purpose of the contract for one of the parties. From an Islamic finance perspective, such contracts are often considered invalid because the uncertainty could lead to dispute or injustice. A more permissible model would involve payment only upon the successful delivery of specified, verifiable results, or a service contract where the efforts and their outcomes are clearly defined and predictable.

Read more about nostringspublicrelations.com:
Nostringspublicrelations.com Review & First Look

The Ethics of “Pay for Published Links”

The “Link Building” service offered by Nostringspublicrelations.com states: “Only pay for published links” and “Guaranteed coverage — every link counts” from £199/$249 per DA70+ link. This model, while seemingly straightforward from a transactional perspective, raises serious ethical questions regarding the nature of these links. If these links are indeed earned through genuine editorial mentions (e.g., a journalist citing your expert opinion in an article), then paying the PR firm for their service in facilitating this earned mention could be permissible, provided the journalist’s decision was truly independent. However, if the “guaranteed coverage” implies that the payment to Nostringspublicrelations.com directly or indirectly influences the media outlet to publish a link (e.g., through a network of contacts who expect a fee for placement, or through a system that closely resembles buying editorial space), then it becomes problematic. Search engines, like Google, actively penalize websites that engage in buying or selling links for SEO purposes because it manipulates search rankings and misrepresents the organic authority of a website. More importantly, from an Islamic ethical standpoint, if the public believes the link is an organic, editorially independent endorsement, but it was in fact paid for (even indirectly), this constitutes deception (ghish). Businesses must ensure that their marketing efforts are truthful and do not mislead consumers or the public about the origin and intent of media coverage.

Verifying Authenticity and Avoiding Deception

For businesses operating under Islamic principles, the imperative to be truthful (sidq) and just (adl) in all dealings is paramount. This extends to how a brand is presented to the public. If a PR firm’s methods, even if subtly, contribute to a public perception that is not entirely truthful about the origin of media coverage, it is ethically questionable. For example, if a “link” is technically in an editorial piece but was effectively “bought,” it misleads the audience into believing it’s an unbiased, earned endorsement. This undermines trust and can have long-term reputational consequences. Before engaging with any PR firm, businesses should conduct thorough due diligence, requesting concrete examples of their “earned media” placements, understanding the precise methodology for how coverage is secured, and ensuring that all practices align with principles of transparency and honesty. Asking for a clear breakdown of how the “guaranteed links” are obtained, and verifying that these methods do not involve any form of payment to the media outlet for editorial placement, is crucial. Nostringspublicrelations.com Review & First Look